Re: make cvs text agnostic?

2002-08-27 Thread Jouni Heikniemi
On Tue, 27 Aug 2002, Matthew Hannigan wrote: > Would it be a good enhancement to automagically > always extract the file in the natural way > for your platform? The actual format in the > repository would not matter at all; cvs would > just do the right thing. This is exactly how CVS works now,

Re: make cvs text agnostic?

2002-08-27 Thread Frederic Brehm
At 06:59 AM 8/27/2002, Matthew Hannigan wrote: >I've been lurking on the list for a while, >and have noticed that many of the questions >seem to hinge on text files and storing and >extracting them the right way for your platform. The CVS clients already do this. The problem comes when people us

Re: make cvs text agnostic?

2002-08-27 Thread Matthew Hannigan
Frederic Brehm wrote: > The CVS clients already do this. The problem comes when people use a > file system cross mounted on several different kinds of OS, checkout on > one OS, and then edit and commit on another OS. I wonder why people do this? Anyway, it shouldn't matter, should it, even wha

Re: make cvs text agnostic?

2002-08-27 Thread Frederic Brehm
At 09:20 AM 8/27/2002, Matthew Hannigan wrote: JH: > > This is exactly how CVS works now, except that the format > > used in the repo is fixed to be the unixish text file format. Disclaimer about the CVS NT server: this may or may not be true...I don't know. >Even when the client and server are

Re: make cvs text agnostic?

2002-08-27 Thread Jouni Heikniemi
On Tue, 27 Aug 2002, Matthew Hannigan wrote: > Jouni Heikmniemi also mentioned that 8bit text would make it difficult. > I still think that for the typical case (source code) the detection > would be quite reliable. Depends. But I think that writing a frontend which would ask a confirmation

Re: make cvs text agnostic?

2002-08-27 Thread Kaz Kylheku
On Tue, 27 Aug 2002, Matthew Hannigan wrote: > I've been lurking on the list for a while, > and have noticed that many of the questions > seem to hinge on text files and storing and > extracting them the right way for your platform. > > Would it be a good enhancement to automagically > always ex

Re: make cvs text agnostic?

2002-08-27 Thread Richard Wesley
>On Tue, 27 Aug 2002, Matthew Hannigan wrote: > > > Autodetection of binary, and perfect reversible >> conversion between text formats is quite feasible, >> so this scheme should fly > >Autodetecting between binary and text is far from trivial. It's fairly >easy when you're talking about En

Re: make cvs text agnostic?

2002-08-27 Thread Paul Sander
>--- Forwarded mail from [EMAIL PROTECTED] >Frederic Brehm wrote: >> The CVS clients already do this. The problem comes when people use a >> file system cross mounted on several different kinds of OS, checkout on >> one OS, and then edit and commit on another OS. >I wonder why people do this?

Re: make cvs text agnostic?

2002-08-27 Thread Koti
Hi, I would like share my thaughts on "Having repository in one OS and development in other OSes" Actually I am windows developer, working on C++, VC++, etc those application I can not develop in UNIX platforlms and at same time there is no better source management tools on windows like CVS. S

Re: make cvs text agnostic?

2002-08-28 Thread Matthew Herrmann
hi all, re this conversation of file types -- why autodetect them, isn't that the whole point of a file type, given in every file's extension? heuristic detection of binariness -- yuck! a mechanism already exists to tell with this problem -- why don't people just make a whopper of a cvswrappers

Re: make cvs text agnostic?

2002-08-28 Thread Paul Sander
>--- Forwarded mail from [EMAIL PROTECTED] >re this conversation of file types -- why autodetect them, isn't that the >whole point >of a file type, given in every file's extension? heuristic detection of >binariness -- yuck! That only works if you have a strict naming convention. The canonical

Re: make cvs text agnostic?

2002-08-29 Thread Frederic Brehm
At 09:58 PM 8/28/2002, Matthew Herrmann wrote: >re this conversation of file types -- why autodetect them, isn't that the >whole point >of a file type, given in every file's extension? heuristic detection of >binariness -- yuck! Exactly! >a mechanism already exists to tell with this problem --

RE: make cvs text agnostic?

2002-08-30 Thread Matthew Herrmann
-Original Message- From: Paul Sander [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Thursday, 29 August 2002 10:16 To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: make cvs text agnostic? >--- Forwarded mail from [EMAIL PROTECTED] >re this conversation of file types -- why autodetect them, is

Re: make cvs text agnostic?

2002-08-30 Thread Eric Siegerman
On Sat, Aug 31, 2002 at 09:40:00AM +1000, Matthew Herrmann wrote: > you are working on a project with files called *.doc, some containing text > and some containing binary. People have complained they don't like adding > the -kb and many get it wrong. > > do you > b) say "well from now on don't c

RE: make cvs text agnostic?

2002-08-30 Thread Paul Sander
This can be done either on the command line directly when adding files, or by writing a light wrapper about "cvs add" and supplying a table. >-Original Message- >From: Paul Sander [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] >Sent: Thursday, 29 August 2002 10:16 >To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [