Re: mail server replication

2004-05-23 Thread Paul Dekkers
Hi, Kevin P. Fleming wrote: drbd in combination with heartbeat and a journalling filesystem can do exactly this. You can have Cyrus IMAP running on both servers (different users), with the Cyrus storage areas mirrored to the other server via drbd. When heartbeat notices that one of the servers

Re: mail server replication

2004-05-22 Thread Colin Bruce
Dear Kevin, Yes, we ran UW impa for some time with drbd doing replication and it was very successful. Of course UW imap doesn't have any databases so I don't know whether that would cause a problem with drbd. I guess the worst case would be a reconstruct perhaps but even that would be much better

Re: mail server replication

2004-05-21 Thread Paul Dekkers
Rob, Rob Siemborski wrote: I hope this kind of functionality comes into cyrus once; I assume it is not there yet, I once asked this on the list before ;-) And maybe it shouldn't be too difficult, since there is already a synchronisation mechanism for NNTP in place, if I'm correct. This is very

Re: mail server replication

2004-05-21 Thread Neil Schneider
Paul Dekkers said: Rob, Rob Siemborski wrote: I hope this kind of functionality comes into cyrus once; I assume it is not there yet, I once asked this on the list before ;-) And maybe it shouldn't be too difficult, since there is already a synchronisation mechanism for NNTP in place, if

Re: mail server replication

2004-05-21 Thread Rob Siemborski
On Fri, 21 May 2004, Paul Dekkers wrote: Although I think Gerard likes to see both servers active at the same time, I think the (master-slave kind) synchronisation would be a nice thing to start with. On the other hand, if I see what offlineimap can do, I assume it must be possible with just 2

Re: mail server replication

2004-05-21 Thread Gerard Ceraso
Yeah, master slave sort of thing would work nice. If the server losses an email or two that would be no problem. Plus I can always set up an MX record for both servers so it would be delivered no matter what. This way if one server goes down I have the other as a backup and if server one catches

Re: mail server replication

2004-05-21 Thread Colin Bruce
Dear Paul and others, I haven't tried it yet but it may be that DRBD (http://www.drbd.org) might be able to do what you want. We used it with a UW Imap server and I don't see why it shouldn't work with Cyrus. It is probably possible to split the users between two cyrus servers and have each

Re: mail server replication

2004-05-21 Thread Kevin P. Fleming
Colin Bruce wrote: I haven't tried it yet but it may be that DRBD (http://www.drbd.org) might be able to do what you want. We used it with a UW Imap server and I don't see why it shouldn't work with Cyrus. It is probably possible to split the users between two cyrus servers and have each group

mail server replication

2004-05-20 Thread Gerard Ceraso
I have a server setup using Cyrus 2.1 and postfix, with mysql. What I would like to have is 2 servers basically the second would be a replication of the first server. So I would like to be able to connect to either at any given time and get my mail and the mail being the same on both mainly for

Re: mail server replication

2004-05-20 Thread Paul Dekkers
Gerard, Gerard Ceraso wrote: I have a server setup using Cyrus 2.1 and postfix, with mysql. What I would like to have is 2 servers basically the second would be a replication of the first server. So I would like to be able to connect to either at any given time and get my mail and the mail being

Re: mail server replication

2004-05-20 Thread Rob Siemborski
On Thu, 20 May 2004, Paul Dekkers wrote: I hope this kind of functionality comes into cyrus once; I assume it is not there yet, I once asked this on the list before ;-) And maybe it shouldn't be too difficult, since there is already a synchronisation mechanism for NNTP in place, if I'm correct.