I'm not sure if this is a bug, an oversight, or something that is known
and deemed not-worth-fixing, so I thought I would ask here first.
Consider the SPL_Types extension. This extension introduces some
classes that override assignment in order to do some type-checked
autoboxing:
$int = new SplInt;
$int = 5;
//$int is not overwritten with scalar '5', but is now SplInt(5).
$int = 'foo';
//throws UnexpectedValueException: Value not an integer
That is a pretty neat thing. However, I would see the primary use-case
for this as the following:
function foo(SplInt $int)
{
//some code
}
foo(5);
Unfortunately, this produces "Catchable fatal error: argument 1 passed
to foo() must be an instance of SplInt, integer given". This, however,
works:
$int = new SplInt;
$int = 5;
foo($int);
Does it seem like a good idea for the type checking mechanism for type
hinted parameters to check whether the hinted class has overridden
assignment, and if so, delegate the type checking to that mechanism?
For example,
foo('bar');
would yield 'UnexpectedValueException: Value not an integer', rather
than the catchable fatal error associated with the type hinted parameter.
Or, perhaps there is something that the extension itself could be doing
to make this happen? Or, perhaps this intentionally does not happen?
I know that genuine scalar type hints are kinda-sorta-maybe on the table
for a future version, but as of right now using the SPL Types to emulate
that in a performant way would be pretty neat.
Thanks,
Jeremy
P.S. - As a side note - I wonder whether it would be possible to make
accessible from userspace the functionality that SPL_Types uses to
override assignment? For example, you could have an __assign($value)
magic method that, if present, would be invoked when attempting to
assign a value to an existing object:
class Foo
{
public function __assign($value)
{
echo $value;
}
}
$foo = new Foo;
$foo = 'foobar'; //outputs foobar
echo ($foo instanceof Foo); //output 1
That's not something I'm really requesting - just an interesting
thought. I'm sure that operator overloading has been brought up and
shot down before, and that functionality is dangerously close to such.
But yeah.
--
PHP Internals - PHP Runtime Development Mailing List
To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php
