Dear Stan:
On 01 Aug 2012, at 01:23, Stan Vass wrote:
1. Name collisions between a trait method and a class method using the trait
go unreported, the class silently shadowing the trait method:
The methods in the class have *always* higher precedence.
This is the same 'overriding' behavior used for inheritance.
From my personal perspective, changing this would lead to a major
inconsistency with how subclassing works.
Hi, I've subsequently read your RFC carefully and saw some of those
Could you please point me *exactly* to the paragraph where we have
something written about static properties? I do not see that I wrote
anything special about static properties in the RFC. And I do not find it
in the docs either. static properties should work like normal properties.
I'd like
Hi Stan:
On 01 Aug 2012, at 13:54, Stan Vass wrote:
The methods in the class have *always* higher precedence.
This is the same 'overriding' behavior used for inheritance.
From my personal perspective, changing this would lead to a major
inconsistency with how subclassing works.
Hi, I've
From that follows that traits override the super class's methods.
And, conflict resolution is only done between traits, not between a class
and its traits.
The class body is a definite thing. Why would you purposefully add
something to a class body that conflicts with a trait?
The class needs
Hi Stan:
On 01 Aug 2012, at 14:56, Stan Vass wrote:
From that follows that traits override the super class's methods.
And, conflict resolution is only done between traits, not between a class
and its traits.
The class body is a definite thing. Why would you purposefully add something
to a
Because it is not a matter of horizontal reuse.
Why don't you get a warning when you override an inherited method?
Because that is precisely the way things are supposed to work.
The body of a class is not a trait. These methods are not 'equals'.
I still think that design decision is a sensible
I'd like to apologize for my language. My goal isn't to insult anybody,
especially PHP contributors of major features like traits.
I hope we can talk strictly implementation issues, I think I have a good
idea how we can move this forward, I'll email you a list of behavior changes
that I think
On 01 Aug 2012, at 16:31, Stan Vass wrote:
Because it is not a matter of horizontal reuse.
Why don't you get a warning when you override an inherited method?
Because that is precisely the way things are supposed to work.
The body of a class is not a trait. These methods are not 'equals'.
On 07/31/2012 04:23 PM, Stan Vass wrote:
I'd like to point out some puzzling behaviors in Traits as they exist in the
production releases of PHP 5.4.
Regardless of the outcome of the mail thread, can you review the traits tests
and create new tests for
any behaviour not already covered?
I'd like to point out some puzzling behaviors in Traits as they exist in the
production releases of PHP 5.4.
1. Name collisions between a trait method and a class method using the trait go
unreported, the class
11 matches
Mail list logo
