Re: inevitability of PI

2003-08-17 Thread Leif Johansson
Mans Nilsson wrote: Still, I wonder why I'm debating this here. It is v6ops material. Hmm Yes. One of the ops ADs even spoke up to support Måns in this, which is a hint as good as any imho. Go request a slot for a renumbering-BOF at the next IETF and lets move on. Cheers Leif

RE: inevitability of PI

2003-08-17 Thread Tony Hain
Forming a WG to fantasize about renumbering will not suddenly remove the edge network manager's requirement for stable address space. The only way this comes close to being an Ops problem is due to the lack of reliability scale in DNS. As long as end users feel that name resolution is

Re: inevitability of PI

2003-08-17 Thread Keith Moore
For once, Tony and I are in agreement. This has nothing to do with operations; it has everything to do with the programming model that the v6 Internet supports. But I'll go even farther. You can improve DNS reliability a bit through saner operations, but you still can't make DNS good enough to