Re: Appel due to management of the "site-local issue"

2003-08-14 Thread Keith Moore
> I respectfully ask that the ADs to confirm the decision made in San > Francisco, later confirmed on the mailing list, and ask the wg chairs > to please move on, working on real issues regarding ipv6 than beating > this dead horse once again. I concur. Keith

Appel due to management of the "site-local issue"

2003-08-14 Thread Leif Johansson
During the IETF meeting in San Francisco, rough consensus found that site-local was to be deprecated. The wg was to investigate other approaches to the problems site-local claims to solve. It should be noted that the wg chairs explicitly before the meeting in San Francisco asked people not dir

Re: Appel due to management of the "site-local issue"

2003-08-14 Thread Mans Nilsson
Subject: Appel due to management of the "site-local issue" Date: Tue, Aug 05, 2003 at 11:41:24AM +0200 Quoting Leif Johansson ([EMAIL PROTECTED]): > I respectfully ask that the ADs to confirm the decision made in San > Francisco, later confirmed on the > mailing list, and a

Re: Appel due to management of the "site-local issue"

2003-08-14 Thread Leif Johansson
Bob Hinden wrote: Leif, You didn't address this to me, but I feel obligated to answer. The questions I have asked the working group in the email "Moving forward on Site-Local and Local Addressing" was to ascertain the manner in which the working group wanted the deprecation of site-local was

Re: Appel due to management of the "site-local issue"

2003-08-10 Thread Thomas Narten
Leif Johansson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > Currently the question about the future and status of site-locals is > again beeing discussed in the wg despite the fact that consensus was > achieved in SF and confirmed on the mailing-list. To be clear, my understanding is: 1) There was clear consen

Re: Appel due to management of the "site-local issue"

2003-08-06 Thread Leif Johansson
Thomas Narten wrote: To be clear, are you filing a formal appeal? If so, you need to be very clear about which action you are appealing, on what grounds, what the remedy should be, and so forth. Also, per 2026, the first place to start with an appeal is the chairs. Only if you are not satisfied wi

Re: Appel due to management of the "site-local issue"

2003-08-06 Thread Bob Hinden
Leif, You didn't address this to me, but I feel obligated to answer. The questions I have asked the working group in the email "Moving forward on Site-Local and Local Addressing" was to ascertain the manner in which the working group wanted the deprecation of site-local was to happen. The ste