On Thu, 23 Jan 2003 20:09:41 +0100 (CET)
Erik Nordmark <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> > > But when server.example.com has that is just GUPI then mail
> > > delivery to [EMAIL PROTECTED] will fail when the GUPI is not
> > > reachable, right?
> >
> > Yes it will. But not because you listed a GU
> > But when server.example.com has that is just GUPI then mail
> > delivery to [EMAIL PROTECTED] will fail when the GUPI is not reachable,
> > right?
>
> Yes it will. But not because you listed a GUPI in the DNS, but because you
> failed to provide and advertise a server that was reachable
On Thu, 23 Jan 2003 09:10:08 +0100 (CET)
Erik Nordmark <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>
> > I do not believe it is either necessary or appropriate to have DNS
> > provide only addresses that are reachable by the party making the query.
>
> The question in my mind is whether it is appropriate to put
> I do not believe it is either necessary or appropriate to have DNS
> provide only addresses that are reachable by the party making the query.
The question in my mind is whether it is appropriate to put addresses
that are by design not globally reachable in the DNS.
> Nor should DNS be used as
> Erik Nordmark wrote:
> But the private interconnects seem to imply that there needs to
> be more than two faces - one for each set of set of sites that
> use GUPI/GUSL for private interconnects I think.
Yes.
> Has anybody thought through how this would work? With recursive
> resolvers?
No. Wit
> One thing I haven't seen discussed in the GUPI/GUSL threads is
> how folks envision they and DNS to fit together for the lookups
> especially when GUPI is used for private interconnects between sites
> (whether it is site-to-site or goes through some ISPs through private
> arrangements).
I
One thing I haven't seen discussed in the GUPI/GUSL threads is
how folks envision they and DNS to fit together for the lookups
especially when GUPI is used for private interconnects between sites
(whether it is site-to-site or goes through some ISPs through private
arrangements).
For the pl