Re: [IPsec] Reopening issue #12

2009-05-03 Thread Stephen Kent
At 2:18 PM +0300 4/29/09, Tero Kivinen wrote: ... In most case I would not expect Bob to create the old SA that way at all, as it would require it to combine two SPD rules together when accepting such entry. As the SPD entries are ordered list that would mean it was combining two entries which

[IPsec] Issue #57: Clarify D-H transform

2009-05-03 Thread Yaron Sheffer
Yaron: 3.3.2: there is no explanation here or elsewhere that the D-H transform for ESP and AH is used for PFS. Paul (off list): Not done. I don't think it belongs in 3.3.2, and I also don't agree that the transform is the D-H transform for ESP and AH is used for PFS; that's an

[IPsec] Issue #58: Access control: add ref to IPsec architecture

2009-05-03 Thread Yaron Sheffer
Yaron: 3.5: this section is extremely liberal on what access control policies people can implement, but that's too late to change now. However, we CAN at least add a reference to RFC 4301, Sec. 4.4.3.1 (as was done in RFC 4945, pki4ipsec). Paul: Not done, take to the list. Yaron: I propose to