[IPsec] Traffic visibility - consensus call

Hi, We have had a few "discusses" during the IESG review of the WESP draft. To help resolve them, we would like to reopen the following two questions to WG discussion. Well reasoned answers are certainly appreciated. But plain "yes" or "no" would also be useful in judging the group's consensus.

Re: [IPsec] IPsec Digest, Vol 68, Issue 49

Tero Kivinen writes: > David Wierbowski writes: > > I think it is reasonable to expect that an IKEv2 bis implementation would > > use an IF statement to control sending the new Notify types. > > No they should just use new notifies, as all old complient > implementations will work with those new

Re: [IPsec] Traffic visibility - consensus call

On Jan 5, 2010, at 12:27 AM, Yaron Sheffer wrote: > Hi, > > We have had a few "discusses" during the IESG review of the WESP draft. To > help resolve them, we would like to reopen the following two questions to WG > discussion. Well reasoned answers are certainly appreciated. But plain "yes"