Re: narten's review of 2461bis

2006-11-30 Thread Brian E Carpenter
Some of other standards track documents have extended ND. Some of these extensions should be mentioned in this document, as some of them seem to actually update this document. I don't see how we can do that in a Draft Standard, since those documents are presumably only Proposed Standard.

Re: narten's review of 2461bis

2006-11-30 Thread Thomas Narten
Some of other standards track documents have extended ND. Some of these extensions should be mentioned in this document, as some of them seem to actually update this document. I don't see how we can do that in a Draft Standard, since those documents are presumably only Proposed Standard.

Re: narten's review of 2461bis

2006-11-30 Thread Brian E Carpenter
Thomas Narten wrote: Some of other standards track documents have extended ND. Some of these extensions should be mentioned in this document, as some of them seem to actually update this document. I don't see how we can do that in a Draft Standard, since those documents are presumably only

RE: narten's review of 2461bis

2006-11-30 Thread Hesham Soliman
Hi Thomas, Thanks for the detailed review. I have some comments inline: Overall: I think this document is in good shape and mostly ready to go forward. But I found a few things that need clarification and some probably warrant some additional discussion. Note: I don't see any of these

Re: narten's review of 2461bis

2006-11-30 Thread Brian Haley
Thomas Narten wrote: For changes to the router intervals, that seems like the kind of minor change/clarification that has been allowed in other documents. And note that we are _recycling_ at draft, not _advancing_ to draft. A discussion about advertisement intervals happened back on 10/29/06 -

Re: narten's review of 2461bis

2006-11-30 Thread Erik Nordmark
Thomas Narten wrote: CurHopLimitThe default hop limit to be used when sending (unicast) IP packets. why only unicast? seems like this should also apply to multicast. Are the default values for multicast different than unicast? (I think the answer is yes