Re: Automatic source routing

2013-09-25 Thread Emmanuel Thierry
Le 25 sept. 2013 à 13:28, Phil Mayers a écrit : > On 25/09/13 11:48, Sander Steffann wrote: >> Hi, >> >>> My reading of his original email was that he was *sending* pings, >>> not receiving them. Perhaps I was mistaken. >> >> Sorry, you are correct. He wrote: >> >>> Unfortunately, when perform

Re: Automatic source routing

2013-09-25 Thread Phil Mayers
On 25/09/13 11:48, Sander Steffann wrote: Hi, My reading of his original email was that he was *sending* pings, not receiving them. Perhaps I was mistaken. Sorry, you are correct. He wrote: Unfortunately, when performing, for instance, a ping from one specific interface or source address, t

Re: Automatic source routing

2013-09-25 Thread Sander Steffann
Hi, > My reading of his original email was that he was *sending* pings, not > receiving them. Perhaps I was mistaken. Sorry, you are correct. He wrote: > Unfortunately, when performing, for instance, a ping from one specific > interface or source address, the ping always use the most recent de

Re: Automatic source routing

2013-09-25 Thread Phil Mayers
On 25/09/13 11:17, Sander Steffann wrote: Hi, But I note that the OP is *currently* testing with a single hosts w/ two interfaces, so host-based source address selection is what's in play here, not (s,d) routing. It's not source address selection if the host is replying to an incoming (ICMP p

Re: Automatic source routing

2013-09-25 Thread Tim Chown
On 25 Sep 2013, at 11:17, Sander Steffann wrote: > Hi, > >> But I note that the OP is *currently* testing with a single hosts w/ two >> interfaces, so host-based source address selection is what's in play here, >> not (s,d) routing. > > It's not source address selection if the host is replyi

Re: Automatic source routing

2013-09-25 Thread Emmanuel Thierry
Le 25 sept. 2013 à 11:40, Ole Troan a écrit : > >>> >>> you need source address dependent routing (e.g. >>> http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-troan-homenet-sadr-01) >>> I think the latest kernel has SADR working. enable CONFIG_IPV6_SUBTREES. >> >> I didn't know this draft, interesting. >> Abou

Re: Automatic source routing

2013-09-25 Thread Sander Steffann
Hi, > But I note that the OP is *currently* testing with a single hosts w/ two > interfaces, so host-based source address selection is what's in play here, > not (s,d) routing. It's not source address selection if the host is replying to an incoming (ICMP ping) packet. The source address is fi

Re: Automatic source routing

2013-09-25 Thread Phil Mayers
On 24/09/13 23:21, Tim Chown wrote: On 24 Sep 2013, at 23:13, Phil Mayers wrote: Ole Troan wrote: you need source address dependent routing (e.g. http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-troan-homenet-sadr-01) I think the latest kernel has SADR working. enable CONFIG_IPV6_SUBTREES. cheers, Ole

Re: Automatic source routing

2013-09-25 Thread Sander Steffann
Hi Ole, > I'm doing the same as you are with a Cisco IOS router. which also has some > shortcomings that I'm working on ironing out. Woohoo! :-) Sander

Re: Automatic source routing

2013-09-25 Thread Ole Troan
Emmanuel, > The problem is really annoying if you want to use autoconfiguration > in a multihoming scenario without the need for an external daemon. > But maybe i missed a sysctl flag or something like that. Maybe, maybe not. What system are you using to manage your networki

Re: Automatic source routing

2013-09-25 Thread Emmanuel Thierry
Hello, Le 24 sept. 2013 à 23:44, Ole Troan a écrit : > Emmanuel, > The problem is really annoying if you want to use autoconfiguration in a multihoming scenario without the need for an external daemon. But maybe i missed a sysctl flag or something like that. >>> >>> Maybe, maybe