Re: [The Java Posse] Re: TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread phil swenson
perhaps you misunderstood me. by "quite a bit higher" I meant higher than the 0.1% that Cedric cited. Certainly not higher than Java. Scala is very much a niche. I just think it's a bigger niche than 0.1% for the type of people on this list. BTW, I am not a Scala advocate. On Wed, Sep 7, 2011

Re: [The Java Posse] Re: TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread opinali
On Wednesday, September 7, 2011 1:05:20 PM UTC-4, phil swenson wrote: > > Scala is probably quite a bit higher on the "non-crappy jobs index" > Most java jobs are doing maintenance work on crappy legacy systems. > > Any language that has been successful for a significant time will have a relativel

Re: [The Java Posse] Re: TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread andy
Hi Martin/all Another place to get jobs charts, at least for the UK, is itjobswatch.co.ukFor Scala in city of london its www.itjobswatch.co.uk/jobs/city%20of%20london/scala.do This currently gives Scala 1.2% with F# at 0.7%, Java at 35% of all jobs (giving scala about 3.5 of all Java jobs, but

Re: [The Java Posse] Re: TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread Fabrizio Giudici
On 09/07/2011 08:07 PM, Kirk wrote: Cedric, +1, measure of error and a fine one at that! I consider Tiobe a useful measure of gross values of most popular stuff. So, ok for the top of the list, ok for aggregates (I've recently blogged about the overall static-vs-dynamic typing). Given tha

Re: [The Java Posse] Re: TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread Kirk
Cedric, +1, measure of error and a fine one at that! On Sep 7, 2011, at 6:34 PM, Cédric Beust ♔ wrote: > On Wed, Sep 7, 2011 at 8:44 AM, martin wrote: > As an antidote to Tiobe: > > http://www.indeed.com/jobtrends?q=Scala%2C+f%23&l= > > This shows Scala at 0.02% of the jobs posted on t

Re: [The Java Posse] Re: TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread martin
I have no idea what the "relative growth" in that chart would be measuring, and would doubt it's anything useful. The absolute numbers I showed give a perspective that sharply differs from Tiobe, that's why I showed them. By comparison, jobs for Scala are bit less than 1% of all Java jobs in US

Re: [The Java Posse] Re: TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread jon.kipar...@gmail.com
"The magic of measuring growth in percents vs/ absolutes." It's good to remember that "fastest growing" is usually shorthand for "smallest" in marketing-speak. - Reply message - From: "Cédric Beust ♔" Date: Wed, Sep 7, 2011 12:34 pm Subject: [The Java Posse] Re: TIOBE of the month: Jav

Re: [The Java Posse] Re: TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread phil swenson
ever since I saw "Go" soar to #13 a couple years ago, I have had a very skeptical view of TIOBE. It was so obviously wrong in that case. 2011/9/7 Cédric Beust ♔ : > > On Wed, Sep 7, 2011 at 6:08 AM, Steel City Phantom > wrote: >> >> after reading the definition of the TIOBE rating, this is pre

Re: [The Java Posse] Re: TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread martin
As an antidote to Tiobe: http://www.indeed.com/jobtrends?q=Scala%2C+f%23&l= Job trends is a pretty non-hypey measure IMO. Note that Scala was close to top 20 around March 2010. Since then it fell back a lot, seemingly because Tiobe changed their measurement criteria. I have frankly no idea wh

Re: [The Java Posse] TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread Matthew Farwell
Just done the same query on with java, and I get +"java programming language" : 2,570,000 results +"java programming" : 8,990,000 results which means that if we take +" programming", we have a factor of 61 difference between java and scala. If we take +" programming language" we have factor of 6.

Re: [The Java Posse] TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread Matthew Farwell
Sorry, just correcting myself: 146,000 for +"Scala programming", 412,000 for +"Scala programming language". Sorry, Matthew. 2011/9/7 Matthew Farwell > In fact, the definition used by TIOBE is > > +" programming" > > Which for me gives 42,100 results for +"Scala programming" and 412,000 for >

Re: [The Java Posse] TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread Matthew Farwell
In fact, the definition used by TIOBE is +" programming" Which for me gives 42,100 results for +"Scala programming" and 412,000 for +"Scala programming language", on Google. Which is very interesting. 10 times the difference. Matthew. 2011/9/7 Kevin Wright > Much as I'd hate to accuse TIOBE

Re: [The Java Posse] Re: TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread Cédric Beust ♔
On Wed, Sep 7, 2011 at 6:08 AM, Steel City Phantom wrote: > after reading the definition of the TIOBE rating, this is pretty useless. > the way they determine the mindshare rakes up there with a high school > popularity contest. Say what you will about TIOBE but I've always found that it's cons

Re: [The Java Posse] Re: TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread Steel City Phantom
im kinda surprised C-C++ is still in the top 5, i would have thought short of embedded systems it would be on the decline by now. after reading the definition of the TIOBE rating, this is pretty useless. the way they determine the mindshare rakes up there with a high school popularity contest. i

[The Java Posse] Re: TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread Casper Bang
It's important to take Tiobe with a grain of salt, however I have no problem believing Scala is below top-50. Scala's massive hype machine might be firing on all cylinders, but I reckon there's still a relatively limited crowd of spectators interested in this SUV race in spite of how loud they

Re: [The Java Posse] TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread Kevin Wright
Much as I'd hate to accuse TIOBE of being inherently flawed, here's an interesting gem: Google search for "scala language" = 13,100,000 results for "scala programming language" = 14,500,000 results TIOBE uses the former term... In other information, here's an analysis of the 40 top-visited webs

[The Java Posse] TIOBE of the month: Java still growing, F# enters top 20, scala still languishing in the 51-100 range.

2011-09-07 Thread Reinier Zwitserloot
I really don't know that much about F#, could anybody shed some light on this? Scala's hype machine, at least from where I'm standing (and I guess I'm part of the java community, which remains the undisputing #1, so that's a large community) is pretty amazing, and yet Scala's languished in the