This tune was indeed composed by Freudenthal, and has
nothing to do with drinking songs, whether German or
not.
I haven't had a chance yet to check out Sam Weiss's I'm sure knowledgeable
discourse about "Ein Kelokeinu," but fwiw, Macy Nulman says of
Freudenthal's tune that it was "derive
would appreciate it . If I become interested in the Jewish
music I will certainly cantact you. Thank you and have a good Shabbat.
- Original Message -
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Date: Thursday, May 1, 2003 5:53 pm
Subject: Re: en keloheynu
> Lorele wrote:
>
> I was looking in the 1
Lorele wrote:
I was looking in the 1931 edition of The Jewish Community Songster and
found En Keloheynu, the usual tune that people on this list have
characterized as a "German drinking tune". In this book it is
attributed to J. Freudenthal. Is this true, and what can a
On Thu, 1 May 2003, Lori Cahan-Simon wrote:
> Khaveyrim,
>
> I was looking in the 1931 edition of The Jewish
> Community Songster and found En Keloheynu, the usual
> tune that people on this list have characterized as a
> "German drinking tune". In this book it is
&g
Khaveyrim,
I was looking in the 1931 edition of The Jewish Community Songster and
found En Keloheynu, the usual tune that people on this list have
characterized as a "German drinking tune". In this book it is
attributed to J. Freudenthal. Is this true, and what can anyone tell me
