[jQuery] Re: Performance suggestion: Use object hash instead of regexp

2009-02-03 Thread Eric Garside
The problem I can forsee getting into is the sheer lack of power in a hash. It's stock and faster for a reason: everything is predefined and a simple check. Try your method vs. jQuery's on the following selector: #somelem.ui-state-active.container .list li a span.enabled That should match only:

[jQuery] Re: Performance suggestion: Use object hash instead of regexp

2009-02-03 Thread George Adamson
Absolutely, it is very very limited. So this technique is only suited to the type of regex's that I quoted, like the one used internally by jquery to test for body or html tags only, or to test for t(able|d|h) only. Particulalry when used inside a loop. For parsing a selector we still need regex.

[jQuery] Re: Performance suggestion: Use object hash instead of regexp

2009-02-03 Thread Eric Garside
In that case, wouldn't a switch statement have even less overhead than creating an object to check everytime? I'd think switch(tag){case 'body':case 'html': /* ... */ break;} would be an even faster solution, no? On Feb 3, 12:39 pm, George Adamson george.adam...@softwareunity.com wrote:

[jQuery] Re: Performance suggestion: Use object hash instead of regexp

2009-02-03 Thread jay
I imagine a switch is the same speed as a hash (switches generally evaluate to a hash). Using a trie structure could be faster than regex in some circumstances I imagine: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trie On Feb 3, 12:45 pm, Eric Garside gars...@gmail.com wrote: In that case, wouldn't a

[jQuery] Re: Performance suggestion: Use object hash instead of regexp

2009-02-03 Thread Karl Swedberg
On Feb 3, 2009, at 12:39 PM, George Adamson wrote: Absolutely, it is very very limited. So this technique is only suited to the type of regex's that I quoted, like the one used internally by jquery to test for body or html tags only, or to test for t(able|d|h) only. Particulalry when used

[jQuery] Re: Performance suggestion: Use object hash instead of regexp

2009-02-03 Thread Ricardo Tomasi
I think this should be posted at jquery-dev. There is no significant difference between the hash and switch options, less than 10ms for 200.000 iterations (FF3). But both offer a solid speed improvement over a simple regex in the case posted when dealing with hundreds of calls. That could be