Graham Leggett wrote:
Mohan Sundaram wrote:
I've my misgivings with this scheme.
What you are doing makes sense only if the number of connections is a
constrained resource. If bandwidth is the constraint, then shaping by
source IP irrespective of number of connections will do the job. As
As Andy muted there are commercial products that will attempt to do this
for you like Allot/Elacoya/DBAM the implementation and testing is where
this scenarios fail.
It sounds good in theory until you do it then all these odd network
errors start occurring. Cause you are now in the debate as
Hi
On Sat, Nov 04, 2006 at 07:08:04AM +0530, Mohan Sundaram wrote:
What you are doing makes sense only if the number of connections is a
constrained resource. If bandwidth is the constraint, then shaping by
source IP irrespective of number of connections will do the job. As far
as I've
What I would like to do instead is allow the user to use any protocol
they like, with the caveat that attempting to open many connections
simultaneously will result in a steadily decreasing share of the pipe,
rather than a steadily increasing one.
I solved this in a similar but slightly
Mohan Sundaram wrote:
I've my misgivings with this scheme.
What you are doing makes sense only if the number of connections is a
constrained resource. If bandwidth is the constraint, then shaping by
source IP irrespective of number of connections will do the job. As far
as I've seen,
Graham Leggett wrote:
In the network in question, bandwidth is minimal (many many users
sharing 512kbps).
You could try WRR. It doesn't work by connection count, but works very
well in scenario you described.
Yours sincerely,
Peter
--
http://www.shurdix.org - Linux distribution for routers
Hi all,
I have been trying to investigate traffic shaping in an effort to solve
the unfriendly network apps problem on a test network.
I have a basis by which I'd like to shape traffic, but studying the
howto doesn't uncover and existing qdisc that seems to fit what I would
like to do.
On Sat, 04 Nov 2006 02:09:03 +0200
Graham Leggett [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Hi all,
I have been trying to investigate traffic shaping in an effort to solve
the unfriendly network apps problem on a test network.
I have a basis by which I'd like to shape traffic, but studying the
howto
Graham Leggett wrote:
Hi all,
I have been trying to investigate traffic shaping in an effort to solve
the unfriendly network apps problem on a test network.
I have a basis by which I'd like to shape traffic, but studying the
howto doesn't uncover and existing qdisc that seems to fit what I
