Re: [OSM-legal-talk] attributing cc by attribution data

2008-01-10 Thread Robin Paulson
On 10/01/2008, Sebastian Spaeth <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > it's been talked about regarding a couple of other issues that have > > cropped up (the naming dispute over cyprus for instance) - maybe we > > need to lock some information, and allow it only to be edited by > > certain privileged admi

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] attributing cc by attribution data

2008-01-10 Thread Sebastian Spaeth
Robin Paulson wrote: > one possible problem i can see: > it is a legal requirement of OSM to display that attribution and if > the tag is editable by anyone, then it can be changed, either through > malice, clumsiness or otherwise. this could lead to troublesome legal > wrangles > > it's been talk

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] attributing cc by attribution data

2008-01-10 Thread Sebastian Spaeth
Frederik Ramm wrote: > I think we could create a new tag "attribution=...", and modify > renderers to include a list of all "attribution" values. For slippy > map displays this would probably require an extra server of sorts that > returns a nice concatenated attribution string for any area. That >

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] attributing cc by attribution data

2008-01-07 Thread Robin Paulson
On 07/01/2008, Frederik Ramm <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > during a discussion [2] around this data, the problem of how to > > attribute it has come up - is there a commonly-used method for > > attributing data in osm? > > > > if not, does anyone have any ideas of how we might accomplish this? >

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] attributing cc by attribution data

2008-01-06 Thread Frederik Ramm
Hi, > during a discussion [2] around this data, the problem of how to > attribute it has come up - is there a commonly-used method for > attributing data in osm? > > if not, does anyone have any ideas of how we might accomplish this? > > the owner of the site has not yet specified any particular

[OSM-legal-talk] attributing cc by attribution data

2008-01-06 Thread Robin Paulson
there is a business listings website [1] in new zealand which allows re-use of it's data, under a creative commons by attribution license. they have a lot of data which is being considered for inclusion in the osm database - mainly shops, restaurants, takeaways, police and fire stations, etc. duri