Re: [License-discuss] GPL linking exceptions

2012-07-09 Thread Rick Moen
Quoting Chris Travers (ch...@metatrontech.com): > In the GPL v2 it is less clear. At its outer limits however, it can > only permit things prohibited under copyright law. Generally RMS > seems to think this is not permissible, and most other people outside > the FSF don't listen. FSF folks occa

Re: [License-discuss] GPL linking exceptions

2012-07-05 Thread Chris Travers
On Thu, Jul 5, 2012 at 6:39 PM, Bruce Perens wrote: > On 07/05/2012 06:30 PM, Chris Travers wrote: >> >> Generally RMS seems to think this is not permissible, and most other >> people outside the FSF don't listen. > > It is not permissible to modify the GPL text directly. That restriction has > te

Re: [License-discuss] GPL linking exceptions

2012-07-05 Thread Bruce Perens
On 07/05/2012 06:30 PM, Chris Travers wrote: Generally RMS seems to think this is not permissible, and most other people outside the FSF don't listen. It is not permissible to modify the GPL text directly. That restriction has teeth. However, I can't think of a legal mechanism that could be app

Re: [License-discuss] GPL linking exceptions

2012-07-05 Thread Chris Travers
On Mon, Jul 2, 2012 at 9:48 AM, Felix Krause wrote: > Hi everyone, > > does a linking exception to the GPL require approval, or may a software be > called open source whenever it is licensed under the GPL, even when the > publisher grants the user additional rights? > > There are some licenses a

Re: [License-discuss] GPL linking exceptions

2012-07-05 Thread Bruce Perens
There are really two sides to this problem. Is your license still OSI certified, and can you do this legally. Regarding the OSI certification, the question is whether all of the rights granted by the certified license still apply. If this is the case, you can still say that the work is under t

[License-discuss] GPL linking exceptions

2012-07-05 Thread Felix Krause
Hi everyone, does a linking exception to the GPL require approval, or may a software be called open source whenever it is licensed under the GPL, even when the publisher grants the user additional rights? There are some licenses around that add a linking exception to the GPL. The one I use is