Re: Is it possible to sue infringers under the GPL?

2000-03-10 Thread John Cowan
"Rod Dixon, J.D., LL.M." wrote: Well, to be precise, one of you is confusing the common sense meaning of "creator" with the meaning of that term under copyright law. Creation of a patch does not make you a creator under copyright. It seems to me that that depends on the substantial

Re: Is it possible to sue infringers under the GPL?

2000-03-10 Thread John Cowan
David Johnson wrote: If someone sends me a patch with no notice of copyright in the patch, but an attached email that says "here's a fix for your code", who does it belong to? I assume that I can use it in my own code as if it were mine, no questions asked. IANAL, but I think you can treat

Re: Is it possible to sue infringers under the GPL?

2000-03-10 Thread David Johnson
On Fri, 10 Mar 2000, John Cowan wrote: IANAL, but I think you can treat that as a constructive license, since a non-exclusive copyright license need not be in writing. Of course, adding the patcher's name to the contributors list is a matter of civility, not law. Of course I didn't mean to

Is it possible to sue infringers under the GPL?

2000-03-08 Thread Justin Wells
A big problem with the GPL, and other OSS licenses, is that very few people have standing to press a complaint. If someone violate's a GPL license, only the author of the software has the right to press the complaint (or so I think, and I am not a lawyer). Worse, if there are multiple

Re: Is it possible to sue infringers under the GPL?

2000-03-08 Thread Seth David Schoen
Justin Wells writes: A big problem with the GPL, and other OSS licenses, is that very few people have standing to press a complaint. If someone violate's a GPL license, only the author of the software has the right to press the complaint (or so I think, and I am not a lawyer). Worse, if

Re: Is it possible to sue infringers under the GPL?

2000-03-08 Thread David Johnson
On Wed, 08 Mar 2000, Seth David Schoen wrote: Worse, if there are multiple authors, you probably need a majority of them present to press the complaint. How do you find out who the authors of an OSS project are, and how on earth would you track down a majority of them? I'm just