Re: [Lightning-dev] Highly Available Lightning Channels

2023-02-13 Thread ZmnSCPxj via Lightning-dev
Good morning all, > > First of all let's see what types of reputation system exist (and yes, > > this is my very informal categorization): > > > > - First hand experience > > - Inferred experience > > - Hearsay > > > > The first two are likely the setup we all are comfortable with: we ourselves

Re: [Lightning-dev] Jamming Mitigation Call Summary - 02/06

2023-02-13 Thread Clara Shikhelman
Hi Vincent, Thanks to write this down, do you think that it is a good idea > to make a public google calendar (or other kind of shared calendar)? > Let's try this out:

Re: [Lightning-dev] Highly Available Lightning Channels

2023-02-13 Thread Matt Corallo
Thanks Christian, On 2/13/23 7:32 AM, Christian Decker wrote: Hi Matt, Hi Joost, let me chime in here, since we seem to be slowly reinventing all the research on reputation systems that is already out there. First of all let me say that I am personally not a fan of reputation systems in

Re: [Lightning-dev] Highly Available Lightning Channels

2023-02-13 Thread Christian Decker
Hi Matt, Hi Joost, let me chime in here, since we seem to be slowly reinventing all the research on reputation systems that is already out there. First of all let me say that I am personally not a fan of reputation systems in general, just to get my own biases out of the way, now on to the why

Re: [Lightning-dev] Highly Available Lightning Channels

2023-02-13 Thread Matt Corallo
Hi Joost, I’m not sure I agree that lightning is “capital efficient” (or even close to it), but more generally I don’t see why this needs a signal. If nodes start aggressively preferring routes through nodes that reliably route payments (which I believe lnd already does, in effect, to some

[Lightning-dev] Highly Available Lightning Channels

2023-02-13 Thread Joost Jager
Hi, For a long time I've held the expectation that eventually payers on the lightning network will become very strict about node performance. That they will require a routing node to operate flawlessly or else apply a hefty penalty such as completely avoiding the node for an extended period of