Andrew Hawryluk ahawry...@gmail.com writes:
2009/8/5 John Mandereau john.mander...@gmail.com:
dots.ly before
dots.ly after
collision-mesh.ly before
collision-mesh.ly after
I think even this simple case might fail if the dots were placed in
the Voice context:
c''4. \\ b'4.
In the
Andrew Hawryluk wrote:
I think even this simple case might fail if the dots were placed in
the Voice context:
c''4. \\ b'4.
Yes, but I would consider this a mesh. If there is a way to test
for that, this situation would not qualify for moving the engraver
to the Voice context.
- Mark
On the user list, Nick Payne shed light on a potential problem
with the Dot_column_engraver.
http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/lilypond-user/2009-08/msg00132.html
Looking at an example from Ted Ross (see attached png), I'm
thinking that Dot_column_engraver may be better suited in the
Voice
Mark Polesky markpole...@yahoo.com writes:
On the user list, Nick Payne shed light on a potential problem
with the Dot_column_engraver.
http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/lilypond-user/2009-08/msg00132.html
Looking at an example from Ted Ross (see attached png), I'm
thinking that
Looking at an example from Ted Ross (see attached png), I'm
thinking that Dot_column_engraver may be better suited in the
Voice context than in the Staff context.
Good idea.
Werner
___
lilypond-devel mailing list
lilypond-devel@gnu.org
2009/8/5 Mark Polesky markpole...@yahoo.com:
Looking at an example from Ted Ross (see attached png), I'm
thinking that Dot_column_engraver may be better suited in the
Voice context than in the Staff context.
Mark, can you make this change on your own, modify the documentation
accordingly
Valentin Villenave wrote:
Mark, can you make this change on your own, modify the documentation
accordingly (don't forget NEWS), and make sure it doesn't break
anything (esp. wrt regtests)? If you do all of this, I think it should
be safe for you to push the change (if any problem occurs
Han-Wen Nienhuys wrote:
I'm
thinking that Dot_column_engraver may be better suited in the
Voice context than in the Staff context.
I suspect that this will give many collisions (dots on top of
noteheads) when this is combined with polyphonic chords. Did you
runthis through the
2009/8/5 Mark Polesky markpole...@yahoo.com:
I didn't, but unfortunately my system can hardly do anything these
days... If someone else would like to run the regtests with this
change, that would be great.
Try running `collision-mesh.ly' to see what happens. :)
Regards,
Neil
Neil Puttock wrote:
Try running `collision-mesh.ly' to see what happens. :)
Where's that?
- Mark
___
lilypond-devel mailing list
lilypond-devel@gnu.org
http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-devel
2009/8/5 Mark Polesky markpole...@yahoo.com:
Where's that?
http://git.savannah.gnu.org/gitweb/?p=lilypond.git;a=blob;f=input/regression/collision-mesh.ly;h=53b02aa4cbda8e1c8834a72046b980d500a5a975;hb=HEAD
___
lilypond-devel mailing list
Mark Polesky wrote:
Try running `collision-mesh.ly' to see what happens. :)
Where's that?
Oh, I see, it's a regression test. How do I run a regression test?
- Mark
___
lilypond-devel mailing list
lilypond-devel@gnu.org
Mark Polesky wrote:
Try running `collision-mesh.ly' to see what happens. :)
Where's that?
Oh, I see, it's a regression test. How do I run a regression test?
Oh, right.
I think I'm going to stop now, since I'm clearly just being stupid.
Sorry.
- Mark
Le mercredi 05 août 2009 à 22:13 +0100, Neil Puttock a écrit :
Try running `collision-mesh.ly' to see what happens. :)
Indeed :-P
dots.ly before
dots.ly after
collision-mesh.ly before
collision-mesh.ly after
John
attachment: lily-cbbf29d5.compare.jpegattachment:
Neil Puttock wrote:
Try running `collision-mesh.ly' to see what happens. :)
Okay, so dots.ly looks better and collision-mesh.ly looks worse.
So what's the solution? This is probably ridiculous, but if there
were some way to test for meshing, so that the Dot_column_engraver
would stay in
2009/8/5 John Mandereau john.mander...@gmail.com:
dots.ly before
dots.ly after
collision-mesh.ly before
collision-mesh.ly after
I think even this simple case might fail if the dots were placed in
the Voice context:
c''4. \\ b'4.
In the example that Mark found, the non-aligned notes are
16 matches
Mail list logo
