Re: Simultaneous dotted notes

2023-01-03 Thread Paul Hodges
On 02/01/2023 16:39:00, "Pierre Perol-Schneider" wrote: (a) Is the Lilypond default presentation really the better way of indicating this? If so, I can just leave it alone. Otherwise, Yes it is, AFAIK (See E. Gould as ref. as far as I remember) In this specific instance I disagree. See

Re: Simultaneous dotted notes

2023-01-03 Thread Paul Hodges
On 02/01/2023 16:39:00, "Pierre Perol-Schneider" wrote: (a) Is the Lilypond default presentation really the better way of indicating this? If so, I can just leave it alone. Otherwise, Yes it is, AFAIK (See E. Gould as ref. as far as I remember) Gould, top of page 59: "Unless conditions a

Re: Simultaneous dotted notes

2023-01-02 Thread Pierre Perol-Schneider
Hi Paul, Le lun. 2 janv. 2023 à 18:36, Paul Hodges a écrit : > In this instance I disagree. > > > See Gould, p59 (near top): "Unless conditions are cramped, [unison] notes > of different duration take a dot beside each notehead". > Hum, right, I've checked the page. For some reason it was more

Re: Simultaneous dotted notes

2023-01-02 Thread Joel C. Salomon
On Mon, Jan 2, 2023 at 11:39 AM Pierre Perol-Schneider < pierre.schneider.pa...@gmail.com> wrote: > (b) I've tried following the examples in >> https://lilypond.org/doc/v2.24/Documentation/notation/multiple-voices#collision-resolution >> and https://lilypond.org/doc/v2.24/Documentation/learning/mo

Re: Simultaneous dotted notes

2023-01-02 Thread Paul Hodges
From: Pierre Perol-Schneider (a) Is the Lilypond default presentation really the better way of indicating this?  If so, I can just leave it alone.  Otherwise, Yes it is, AFAIK (See E. Gould as ref. as far as I remember)  In this instance I disagree. See Gould, p59 (near top):

Re: Simultaneous dotted notes

2023-01-02 Thread Pierre Perol-Schneider
Hi Joel, Le lun. 2 janv. 2023 à 17:29, Joel C. Salomon a écrit : ... > (a) Is the Lilypond default presentation really the better way of > indicating this? If so, I can just leave it alone. Otherwise, > Yes it is, AFAIK (See E. Gould as ref. as far as I remember) ... > (b) I've tried followi

Simultaneous dotted notes

2023-01-02 Thread Joel C. Salomon
Minimal example: \version "2.24.0" \fixed c { \clef bass << a4.-> \\ 2. >> << a4-> \\ 2. >> } When I look *real* closely, I see four dots the first time and three dots the second; but the attached image shows how this looks in the source score, with the dotted-q