Re: musical logic: what dynamic after the repeat (picture attached)?

2012-03-19 Thread Tim Roberts
Jonas Olson wrote: > Unless forte is considered to be in effect also at the beginning of the > second volta, the attached example becomes strange. (Edited with a music > engraving software called GIMP.) Well, yes, I think most publishers would actually put the notation "f-p" at the beginning of th

Re: musical logic: what dynamic after the repeat (picture attached)?

2012-03-19 Thread Jonas Olson
Unless forte is considered to be in effect also at the beginning of the second volta, the attached example becomes strange. (Edited with a music engraving software called GIMP.) Regards, Jonas Olson <>___ lilypond-user mailing list lilypond-user@gnu.org

Re: musical logic: what dynamic after the repeat (picture attached)?

2012-03-19 Thread Rob Collinson
Hello all. It's my first ever reply to a forum anywhere, so if I've done something wrong I apologise. I should say that in lieu of any further editorial marks or cautionary reminders, the dynamic would be "p" until the end of the music. My crude litmus test would be to imagine the music written

Re: musical logic: what dynamic after the repeat (picture attached)?

2012-03-18 Thread -Eluze
>>> >>> What dynamic is in measure 3 after the repeat? p or f? >>> And yes, I know it is better to write something explicit than implicit. >>> I personally would write a new dynamic sign after ||: but how to >>> interpret it if somebody did it like in the picture? > > 3rd measure after the be

Re: musical logic: what dynamic after the repeat (picture attached)?

2012-03-18 Thread Vaughan McAlley
On 17 March 2012 22:37, Phil Holmes wrote: > - Original Message - From: "Nils" > To: > Sent: Saturday, March 17, 2012 11:30 AM > Subject: musical logic: what dynamic after the repeat (picture attached)? > > > >> Hello list, >> >> What

Re: musical logic: what dynamic after the repeat (picture attached)?

2012-03-17 Thread Phil Holmes
- Original Message - From: "Nils" To: Sent: Saturday, March 17, 2012 11:30 AM Subject: musical logic: what dynamic after the repeat (picture attached)? Hello list, What dynamic is in measure 3 after the repeat? p or f? And yes, I know it is better to write somethin

musical logic: what dynamic after the repeat (picture attached)?

2012-03-17 Thread Nils
Hello list, What dynamic is in measure 3 after the repeat? p or f? And yes, I know it is better to write something explicit than implicit. I personally would write a new dynamic sign after ||: but how to interpret it if somebody did it like in the picture? Nils<>