Re: trill notes

2008-03-05 Thread Kieren MacMillan
Hi Bert, I would say that in C-minor (if the harmonic structure, context etc is C-minor) I would not use Fb, but E, because the flat version of IV grade seems very strange for me, while the neutralized version of III grade is common. If it's a C-minor chord, and the trill is on degree III

Re: trill notes

2008-03-05 Thread Bertalan Fodor (LilyPondTool)
the key is C-minor, and I want a trill on (midinotes) D# and E, what would the correct trill notes be? Depends on the context -- i.e., which note is the "fundamental" and which is the "embellishment", as well as the underlying harmonic structure (chords, etc.). * Is the cor

Re: trill notes

2008-03-05 Thread Kieren MacMillan
Hi Maarten, A generic question: * If the key is C-minor, and I want a trill on (midinotes) D# and E, what would the correct trill notes be? Depends on the context -- i.e., which note is the "fundamental" and which is the "embellishment", as well as the underlying

trill notes

2008-03-05 Thread M.v.Strien
Hi, A generic question: * If the key is C-minor, and I want a trill on (midinotes) D# and E, what would the correct trill notes be? Es E (neutral) -or- Es Fes * Will amateur players and professional players both agree on one method? * Is the correct method suitable for each instrument? Or