Re: [OCLUG-Tech] DKIM and SPF on the list

2014-07-11 Thread Murphy Scott
The list has been returned to its original format. A number of requests to return it came in, so it was reverted to the former behaviour. Scott On Jul 11, 2014, at 3:24 PM, Charles MacDonald wrote: > On 14-07-08 11:14 AM, OCLUG Technical Discussions wrote: >> I have changed the list options to

Re: [OCLUG-Tech] DKIM and SPF on the list

2014-07-11 Thread Charles MacDonald
On 14-07-08 11:14 AM, OCLUG Technical Discussions wrote: I have changed the list options to strip the reply to and the sender, replacing them with the list address. So now, all the messages show as comming from the list, with potentally no way to filter on teh original sender? BTW why are

Re: [OCLUG-Tech] DKIM and SPF on the list

2014-07-08 Thread OCLUG Technical Discussions
To be clear: - tricolour.net (RGB's domain) is complaining to me that lists.oclug.on.ca is doing bad things. On 08/07/14 13:34, OCLUG Technical Discussions wrote: My problem is SPF and DKIM are failing on emails I send through this list and I get notice that someone is doing a bad thing with

Re: [OCLUG-Tech] DKIM and SPF on the list

2014-07-08 Thread OCLUG Technical Discussions
My problem is SPF and DKIM are failing on emails I send through this list and I get notice that someone is doing a bad thing with this domain (including tricolour.net!) So to fix this I suggested removing DKIM headers from my domain. Which would be simple and awesome. The reply-to stuff I don

Re: [OCLUG-Tech] DKIM and SPF on the list

2014-07-08 Thread OCLUG Technical Discussions
On 14/07/08, Jean-Luc cooke wrote: > Emails sent to this list seem to have some DKIM and SPF issues - I > get DMARC failure reports. > > I know DKIM and SPF aren't ideal for this kind of application - but > I suspect there are email and spam experts on the list who can help > - Roaring Penguins, p

Re: [OCLUG-Tech] DKIM and SPF on the list

2014-07-08 Thread OCLUG Technical Discussions
Brett - please provide the proper fix to Scott or explain why there is no proper fix. Let's be constructive. On 08/07/14 11:32, OCLUG Technical Discussions wrote: I have changed the list options to strip the reply to and the sender, replacing them with the list address. Scott B. Wrong a

Re: [OCLUG-Tech] DKIM and SPF on the list

2014-07-08 Thread OCLUG Technical Discussions
I have changed the list options to strip the reply to and the sender, replacing them with the list address. Scott B. Wrong answer / incorrect fix. The fact that I have to point this out to you on the list and cannot reply directly really drives the point home. Please undo this change. I

Re: [OCLUG-Tech] DKIM and SPF on the list

2014-07-08 Thread OCLUG Technical Discussions
I have changed the list options to strip the reply to and the sender, replacing them with the list address. Scott On Jul 8, 2014, at 10:52 AM, Jean-Luc cooke wrote: > Emails sent to this list seem to have some DKIM and SPF issues - I get DMARC > failure reports. > > I know DKIM and SPF aren

[OCLUG-Tech] DKIM and SPF on the list

2014-07-08 Thread Jean-Luc cooke
Emails sent to this list seem to have some DKIM and SPF issues - I get DMARC failure reports. I know DKIM and SPF aren't ideal for this kind of application - but I suspect there are email and spam experts on the list who can help - Roaring Penguins, please stand up? Basically - emails should