staggered stripes

2014-05-15 Thread Russell Coker
software stack has no specific data # structure that is placed at the block numbers of interest. # # These observations indicate that hardware or firmware bugs that affect # specific sets of block numbers might exist. Therefore, RAID system designers # may be well-advised to use staggered stripes

Re: staggered stripes

2014-05-15 Thread Duncan
]herefore, # RAID system designers may be well-advised to use staggered # stripes such that the blocks that form a stripe (providing # the required redundancy) are placed at different block numbers # on different disks. Does the BTRFS RAID functionality do such staggered stripes? If not could

Re: staggered stripes

2014-05-15 Thread Hugo Mills
, RAID system designers # may be well-advised to use staggered stripes such that the blocks that form # a stripe (providing the required redundancy) are placed at different block # numbers on different disks. Does the BTRFS RAID functionality do such staggered stripes? If not could

Re: staggered stripes

2014-05-15 Thread Russell Coker
On Thu, 15 May 2014 09:31:42 Duncan wrote: Does the BTRFS RAID functionality do such staggered stripes? If not could it be added? AFAIK nothing like that yet, but it's reasonably likely to be implemented later. N-way-mirroring is roadmapped for next up after raid56 completion, however

Re: staggered stripes

2014-05-15 Thread Brendan Hide
On 2014/05/15 04:38 PM, Russell Coker wrote: On Thu, 15 May 2014 09:31:42 Duncan wrote: Does the BTRFS RAID functionality do such staggered stripes? If not could it be added? AFAIK nothing like that yet, but it's reasonably likely to be implemented later. N-way-mirroring is roadmapped

Re: staggered stripes

2014-05-15 Thread Hugo Mills
On Fri, May 16, 2014 at 12:38:04AM +1000, Russell Coker wrote: On Thu, 15 May 2014 09:31:42 Duncan wrote: Does the BTRFS RAID functionality do such staggered stripes? If not could it be added? AFAIK nothing like that yet, but it's reasonably likely to be implemented later. N-way

Re: staggered stripes

2014-05-15 Thread Duncan
On Fri, 16 May 2014 00:38:04 +1000 Russell Coker russ...@coker.com.au wrote: You do mention the partition alternative, but not as I'd do it for such a case. Instead of doing a different sized buffer partition (or using the mkfs.btrfs option to start at some offset into the device) on