[linux-dvb] Re: ATTENTION PLEASE: The DVB major device number has changed

2004-07-30 Thread Olaf Titz
Imho it would be better to use 250 for all API-3 drivers, and switch to 212 for API-4. IMHO, this is the best solution to avoid a lot of confusion. API-4 will need many changes to softwares, so a new major shouldn't be too difficult to do at the same time. That way, the big confusion

[linux-dvb] Re: ATTENTION PLEASE: The DVB major device number has changed

2004-07-28 Thread Holger Waechtler
Johannes Stezenbach wrote: Holger Waechtler wrote: Oliver Endriss wrote: On Tuesday 27 July 2004 19:20, Johannes Stezenbach wrote: Hi, I was just informed that LANANA has assigned an official major number for DVB, so we don't have to use the unoffical / experimental use only number 250 anymore.

[linux-dvb] Re: ATTENTION PLEASE: The DVB major device number has changed

2004-07-28 Thread Michael Hunold
Hi, On 07/27/04 19:39, Oliver Endriss wrote: On Tuesday 27 July 2004 19:20, Johannes Stezenbach wrote: The new offical major number is 212. I've changed the sources for dvb-kernel (dvbdev.h and MAKEDEV-DVB.sh). People who don't use devfs will have to recreate their devices. Imho it would be

[linux-dvb] Re: ATTENTION PLEASE: The DVB major device number has changed

2004-07-28 Thread Steffen Barszus
On Wednesday 28 July 2004 08:59, Holger Waechtler wrote: Johannes Stezenbach wrote: And, BTW, udev doesn't obsolete device numbers, it is just a mechanism to create device nodes automatically. :) (like the one that was once called devfs... exactly what everybody wants/needs;) BTW is it

[linux-dvb] Re: ATTENTION PLEASE: The DVB major device number has changed

2004-07-28 Thread Holger Waechtler
Michael Hunold wrote: Hi, On 07/27/04 19:39, Oliver Endriss wrote: On Tuesday 27 July 2004 19:20, Johannes Stezenbach wrote: The new offical major number is 212. I've changed the sources for dvb-kernel (dvbdev.h and MAKEDEV-DVB.sh). People who don't use devfs will have to recreate their devices.

[linux-dvb] Re: ATTENTION PLEASE: The DVB major device number has changed

2004-07-28 Thread C.Y.M.
Maybe a kernel-config option to choose the DVB_MAJOR define used simplifies the transition, especially for people who switch between different kernel version on-the-fly and don't want to recreate their device nodes for every boot... I'm just curious if these old alias' are going to

[linux-dvb] Re: ATTENTION PLEASE: The DVB major device number has changed

2004-07-28 Thread Tim Dodge
Quoting Steffen Barszus [EMAIL PROTECTED]: BTW is it planned to make the drivers udev compatible ? As far as i have understood it will be used in favour of devfs in near future, but a fast try showed me that there are no dvb devices created with udev. Any plans ? Steffen There is a sysfs/udev

[linux-dvb] Re: ATTENTION PLEASE: The DVB major device number has changed

2004-07-27 Thread Oliver Endriss
On Tuesday 27 July 2004 19:20, Johannes Stezenbach wrote: Hi, I was just informed that LANANA has assigned an official major number for DVB, so we don't have to use the unoffical / experimental use only number 250 anymore. Apparently the number was assigned months ago, just nobody

[linux-dvb] Re: ATTENTION PLEASE: The DVB major device number has changed

2004-07-27 Thread Holger Waechtler
Oliver Endriss wrote: On Tuesday 27 July 2004 19:20, Johannes Stezenbach wrote: Hi, I was just informed that LANANA has assigned an official major number for DVB, so we don't have to use the unoffical / experimental use only number 250 anymore. Apparently the number was assigned months ago, just

[linux-dvb] Re: ATTENTION PLEASE: The DVB major device number has changed

2004-07-27 Thread Johannes Stezenbach
Holger Waechtler wrote: Oliver Endriss wrote: On Tuesday 27 July 2004 19:20, Johannes Stezenbach wrote: Hi, I was just informed that LANANA has assigned an official major number for DVB, so we don't have to use the unoffical / experimental use only number 250 anymore. Apparently the

[linux-dvb] Re: ATTENTION PLEASE: The DVB major device number has changed

2004-07-27 Thread Gerd Knorr
Holger Waechtler [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: a heretical thought comes to my mind: isn't it possible to move to a sysfs/udev based filesystem and leave all the struggles of major/minor numbering of chrdevs behind? sysfs support would indead simplify the switchover, as udev can create the device

[linux-dvb] Re: ATTENTION PLEASE: The DVB major device number has changed

2004-07-27 Thread Wolfgang Thiel
On Tue, Jul 27, 2004 at 07:39:32PM +0200, Oliver Endriss wrote: ... The new offical major number is 212. I've changed the sources for dvb-kernel (dvbdev.h and MAKEDEV-DVB.sh). People who don't use devfs will have to recreate their devices. Argh, this will cause a lot of trouble!!!

[linux-dvb] Re: ATTENTION PLEASE: The DVB major device number has changed

2004-07-27 Thread C.Y.M.
The new offical major number is 212. I've changed the sources for dvb-kernel (dvbdev.h and MAKEDEV-DVB.sh). People who don't use devfs will have to recreate their devices. Argh, this will cause a lot of trouble!!! So, in order to fix this, all we have to do is unload the dvb