Re: MODULE_LICENSE usage

2007-08-07 Thread Alan Cox
> People around here use Alcatel/Thomson "Speedtouch" and Sagem > "Fast" USB ADSLs. Linux has open-source drivers for both. > USB seems like an advantage in this case, too - you can connect > to any machine including non-PCI small network storage servers > with non-x86 CPU. In this part of the wor

Re: MODULE_LICENSE usage

2007-08-07 Thread Krzysztof Halasa
"Nathan Williams" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > The binary blob is run in the kernel. I wasn't aware of any > completely open-source drivers for ADSL modems, mine is a PCI ADSL > modem. People around here use Alcatel/Thomson "Speedtouch" and Sagem "Fast" USB ADSLs. Linux has open-source drivers

RE: MODULE_LICENSE usage

2007-08-07 Thread David Schwartz
> My company has been given documentation and the library source under > the terms of an NDA with the chipset manufacturer. We are permitted > to compile the library and distribute the resultant binary blob, but > not release the source to the library. > The binary blob is linked into the driver

RE: MODULE_LICENSE usage

2007-08-07 Thread David Schwartz
> > My company has been given documentation and the library source under > > the terms of an NDA with the chipset manufacturer. We are permitted > > to compile the library and distribute the resultant binary blob, but > > not release the source to the library. > > > > The binary blob is linked in

Re: MODULE_LICENSE usage

2007-08-07 Thread Alan Cox
> My company has been given documentation and the library source under > the terms of an NDA with the chipset manufacturer. We are permitted > to compile the library and distribute the resultant binary blob, but > not release the source to the library. > > The binary blob is linked into the drive

Re: MODULE_LICENSE usage

2007-08-07 Thread Arnd Bergmann
On Tuesday 07 August 2007, Nathan Williams wrote: > My company has been given documentation and the library source under > the terms of an NDA with the chipset manufacturer.  We are permitted > to compile the library and distribute the resultant binary blob, but > not release the source to the libr

Re: MODULE_LICENSE usage

2007-08-06 Thread Nathan Williams
> b) if the binary blob is really a library to be run in kernel (host) > space then there is no point in writing such driver - there are > completely open-source drivers for ADSL devices and most (if not > all) people will prefer them over any binary library. > > Perhaps you can convince the chipse

RE: MODULE_LICENSE usage

2007-08-06 Thread David Schwartz
> I'm working on a driver for an ADSL modem which requires the use of a > binary library from the chipset manufacturer. All my source code is > GPL, so that others are free to distribute and modify the driver. > After asking the FSF for advice and working through their FAQ, I've > given permissio

Re: MODULE_LICENSE usage

2007-08-06 Thread Krzysztof Halasa
Hi, "Nathan Williams" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > I'm working on a driver for an ADSL modem which requires the use of a > binary library from the chipset manufacturer. Legal things aside, the practical solutions are: a) if the binary "library" is just firmware running on modem's CPU (outside

Re: MODULE_LICENSE usage

2007-08-06 Thread Remy Bohmer
Hello Nathan, There has been a lot of discussion about this in the past. Read for example this thread: http://lkml.org/lkml/2006/12/13/370 This will probably clears some things up. Remy 2007/8/6, Nathan Williams <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > Hi, > > I'm working on a driver for an ADSL modem which requi

Re: MODULE_LICENSE usage

2007-08-06 Thread Jan Engelhardt
On Aug 6 2007 17:53, Nathan Williams wrote: >Hi, > >I'm working on a driver for an ADSL modem which requires the use of a >binary library from the chipset manufacturer. All my source code is >GPL, [...] >I've given permission for the binary library file to be used with the GPL >source code and be

Re: MODULE_LICENSE usage

2007-08-06 Thread Alan Cox
> After asking the FSF for advice and working through their FAQ, I've > given permission for the binary library file to be used with the GPL > source code and be re-distributed with it. Only the copyright holder can give additional permissions for a piece of code so for such a change you must have

MODULE_LICENSE usage

2007-08-06 Thread Nathan Williams
Hi, I'm working on a driver for an ADSL modem which requires the use of a binary library from the chipset manufacturer. All my source code is GPL, so that others are free to distribute and modify the driver. After asking the FSF for advice and working through their FAQ, I've given permission for