Re: ICH7 sata-ahci + software raid warning

2006-07-11 Thread Christian Pernegger
Why not just --set-faulty or --fail with mdadm? This is not about testing, but about real errors. 1) I depend on the md layer to tell me if a disk is faulty ... failing the disk manually would only help if I already knew the disk was faulty and just wanted to remove it. 2) If the affected arra

Re: ICH7 sata-ahci + software raid warning

2006-07-11 Thread Christian Pernegger
For ICH5 and all other controllers (non-AHCI) of course, I've always seen md mark it faulty on a bad disk/sector/etc. ICH7 (ahci) does not. At least not a whole disk dieing, don't know about bad sectors. I thought you were just trying to mark it faulty manually for the purpose of rebuilding it

Re: ICH7 sata-ahci + software raid warning

2006-07-11 Thread Justin Piszcz
On Tue, 11 Jul 2006, Francois Barre wrote: 2006/7/11, Justin Piszcz <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: Why not just --set-faulty or --fail with mdadm? If you answer to "Bad blocks maybe, can't test that.", I'll say AFAIK, --set-faulty will only stay at the md layer, and won't go through the underlying d

Re: ICH7 sata-ahci + software raid warning

2006-07-11 Thread Francois Barre
2006/7/11, Justin Piszcz <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: Why not just --set-faulty or --fail with mdadm? If you answer to "Bad blocks maybe, can't test that.", I'll say AFAIK, --set-faulty will only stay at the md layer, and won't go through the underlying driver (sata here, ata elsewhere, ...), so this

Re: ICH7 sata-ahci + software raid warning

2006-07-11 Thread Justin Piszcz
Why not just --set-faulty or --fail with mdadm? On Mon, 10 Jul 2006, Christian Pernegger wrote: I'm (still) trying to setup a md array on the ICH7 SATA controller of an Intel SE7230NH1-E with 4 WD5000YS disks. On this controller (in ahci mode) I have not yet managed to get a disk mark as faile

ICH7 sata-ahci + software raid warning

2006-07-10 Thread Christian Pernegger
I'm (still) trying to setup a md array on the ICH7 SATA controller of an Intel SE7230NH1-E with 4 WD5000YS disks. On this controller (in ahci mode) I have not yet managed to get a disk mark as failed. - a bad cable just led to hangs and timeouts - pulling the power on one of the SATA drives (whi