Hi,
i had the same problem and i found the following solution:
try to delete or set the "dos compatibility flag" on both drives.
You have to do this with fdisks c command.
For mee it looks as if one of your drives has this flag set and the another not.
I hope this helps
##################################################################
# .". #
# /V\ Valeanu Adrian [EMAIL PROTECTED] #
# // \\ GNUPG-Key on request #
# /( )\ PGP-Key on request #
# ^^-^^ #
##################################################################