Re: Academics / Real World

2002-01-04 Thread Tony Bowden
On Fri, Jan 04, 2002 at 01:28:04PM +, robin szemeti wrote: > no .. he's missed the point. > he defines a langauge as 'powerful' based on what it can do .. closures, > continuations, macros etc .. thats bollox > a closure is worth feck all to customers ... > Perl::DBI *is* worth something. ..

Re: Academics / Real World

2002-01-04 Thread Andy Wardley
On Thu, Jan 03, 2002 at 10:42:51AM +, Leon Brocard wrote: > So, is Perl part of the "Worse is Better" crowd? Why did the academics > think that we hadn't done our research? Why can't academics actually > do something to help the real world rather than play with toy > languages that nobody actu

RE: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread Mark Fowler
On Thu, 3 Jan 2002, Ivor Williams wrote: > Then you need the all embracketing perl-to-lisp source code scrunger. Then > everyone is happy. Couldn't we just run LISP on parrot (which is probably simplier.) If you can do that then it's my understanding you could call LISP routines from perl 6 a

RE: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread Ivor Williams
> * robin szemeti ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote: > > > > bah! .. surely you are having a joke? .. Arc got a very warm response it > > seems .. a new dialect of Lisp for the web .. how .. err .. useful. > > > > A new dialect of lisp .. I ask you ... > > > > Ha! You won't be so smug when we are a

Re: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread Greg McCarroll
* robin szemeti ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote: > > bah! .. surely you are having a joke? .. Arc got a very warm response it > seems .. a new dialect of Lisp for the web .. how .. err .. useful. > > A new dialect of lisp .. I ask you ... > Ha! You won't be so smug when we are all running super fa

Re: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread Greg McCarroll
* Paul Mison ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote: > > *cough* Xerox Parc Alto vs Apple Macintosh > > I'd like to think I was alluding to that process when I was wittering > about the original mouse, but point taken, and probably one of the > better case studies of the process (which I hope Greg's recommend

Re: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread Dominic Mitchell
Paul Mison <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > (Oh, and if you don't understand continuations either, I found the best > thread to follow was the third one (Seth Gordon's) although the second > (Bruce Lewis's) was also interesting, as it mentioned that Damien had > previously discussed continuation.) C

Re: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread Dominic Mitchell
Rob Partington <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, > robin szemeti <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > > bah! .. surely you are having a joke? .. Arc got a very warm response it > > seems .. a new dialect of Lisp for the web .. how .. err .. useful. > > http://www.paulgraha

Re: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread Paul Mison
On Thu, Jan 03, 2002 at 02:05:14PM +, the hatter wrote: > On Thu, 3 Jan 2002, Paul Mison wrote: > > > :: paul > > :: not obsessed with macs, oh no > > So you won't have any views on the various rumours about what apple are > going to be announcing, then ? Yes. It'll be underwhelming, despi

Re: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread the hatter
On Thu, 3 Jan 2002, Paul Mison wrote: > :: paul > :: not obsessed with macs, oh no So you won't have any views on the various rumours about what apple are going to be announcing, then ? the hatter

Re: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread Paul Mison
On Thu, Jan 03, 2002 at 12:59:23PM +, Simon Wistow wrote: > On Thu, Jan 03, 2002 at 11:02:07AM +, Paul Mison said: > > > Why did the academics think that we hadn't done our research? > > > > Because Dan admitted he actually hadn't done his research? See: > > > > http://www.ai.mit.edu/~gr

Re: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread Rob Partington
In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, robin szemeti <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > bah! .. surely you are having a joke? .. Arc got a very warm response it > seems .. a new dialect of Lisp for the web .. how .. err .. useful. http://www.paulgraham.com/lib/paulgraham/sec.txt I don't know about you, bu

Re: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread Roger Burton West
On Thu, Jan 03, 2002 at 12:00:58PM +, robin szemeti wrote: >At the end of the day do we care? no. they can sit in their ivory towers >mulling over some new construct that no one will ever use whilst ridiculing >our language, meanwhile 1000's of people are using it every day which >is

Re: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread Simon Wistow
On Thu, Jan 03, 2002 at 11:02:07AM +, Paul Mison said: > > Why did the academics think that we hadn't done our research? > > Because Dan admitted he actually hadn't done his research? See: > > http://www.ai.mit.edu/~gregs/ll1-discuss-archive-html/msg00499.html No, that says that he had done

Re: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread Leon Brocard
Paul Mison sent the following bits through the ether: > Anyway, that's the whole point of academics, to do things that seem > useless at the time, like building strange wooden boxes with rotation > monitors and attaching them to computers and calling them 'mice'... http://citeseer.nj.nec.com/cs?

RE: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread Ivor Williams
Interesting... My conclusions from reading the write up are slightly different, in that this is highlighting a culture clash, between academics and the Perl community. Do we have any representative in the academic world who are eloquent speakers? I have a lot of respect for Dan Sugalski, as he is

Re: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread Greg McCarroll
* Leon Brocard ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote: > > So, is Perl part of the "Worse is Better" crowd? Why did the academics > think that we hadn't done our research? Why can't academics actually > do something to help the real world rather than play with toy > languages that nobody actually uses? > I

Re: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread Mark Fowler
On Thu, 3 Jan 2002, Leon Brocard wrote: > So, is Perl part of the "Worse is Better" crowd? Why did the academics > think that we hadn't done our research? It's a clash of cultures. Academics have to justify everything and explain everything in minute detail. Hand waving is what *we* do. When

Re: Academics / Real World

2002-01-03 Thread Paul Mison
On Thu, Jan 03, 2002 at 10:42:51AM +, Leon Brocard wrote: > http://www.ddj.com/documents/s=2287/ddj0202a/0202a.htm > > So, is Perl part of the "Worse is Better" crowd? Evidently. Simon admitted as much, and even if he hadn't, it would be hard to claim it wasn't. After all, it self-consciousl