[LUTE] Re: Antique tools.

2005-09-22 Thread Jon Murphy
I basically agree with everyone, but choose this message to respond to as I've a bit of disagreement here. > Probably because they make a lot more selling slick-looking but poorly made crap to consumers who don't know any better... Also, there isn't really a big enough market for the more special

[LUTE] Re: Antique tools.

2005-09-22 Thread Carl Donsbach
Another thing is that a variety of useful tools are not commonly made anymore. I like to watch Roy Underhill's show on PBS. He is always using some antique doodad that nobody at Home Depot has heard of, and the modern woodworker of the Norm Abrams school would have little use for. I'm a neoph

[LUTE] Re: Antique tools.

2005-09-22 Thread guy_and_liz Smith
Probably because they make a lot more selling slick-looking but poorly made crap to consumers who don't know any better... Also, there isn't really a big enough market for the more specialized tools to make it worth their while. There are some very well made modern tools, just not by the old st

[LUTE] Re: Antique tools.

2005-09-22 Thread Eugene C. Braig IV
At 11:01 AM 9/22/2005, Herbert Ward wrote: >Larry Brown (on his website) says that many of his tools are >antique, and superior to their modern counterparts. > >The man's woodworking expertise is obvious (and probably >also not obvious). > >So I wonder how it is that Craftsman, Black & Decker, and

[LUTE] Re: Antique tools.

2005-09-22 Thread Craig Allen
Herbert wrote: > >Larry Brown (on his website) says that many of his tools are >antique, and superior to their modern counterparts. > >The man's woodworking expertise is obvious (and probably >also not obvious). > >So I wonder how it is that Craftsman, Black & Decker, and Stanley, >with their engin

[LUTE] Re: Antique tools.

2005-09-22 Thread Doctor Oakroot
Older tools were made of carbon steel which can be sharpened to a very fine edge, but is soft enough to dull with use. Modern tools use harder alloys which do not dull (at least not in your lifetime with reasonable use), but can't be easily resharpened, reshaped, and maybe can't be as sharp as car

[LUTE] Antique tools.

2005-09-22 Thread Herbert Ward
Larry Brown (on his website) says that many of his tools are antique, and superior to their modern counterparts. The man's woodworking expertise is obvious (and probably also not obvious). So I wonder how it is that Craftsman, Black & Decker, and Stanley, with their engineers, experience, capita

[LUTE] Ownership

2005-09-22 Thread Stewart McCoy
Dear Ed, I have a viol-playing friend who once had many cats. He called each of them by the name of a 16th-century English composer - Tallis, Cornish, etc. He avoided the name Byrd, because he thought a cat called Byrd might confuse his children. Best wishes, Stewart McCoy. - Original Mess