[LUTE] Re: Ban the lute

2012-03-14 Thread howard posner
On Mar 14, 2012, at 10:21 AM, Monica Hall wrote: There is a paradox at the heart of the Early Music Movement - we like the music but we don't like the way the people who created it lived their lives. But you can't separate the two. You have to try and understand the world in which they

[LUTE] Re: Ban the lute

2012-03-14 Thread tom
On Mar 14, 2012, at 10:21 AM, Monica Hall wrote: There is a paradox at the heart of the Early Music Movement - we like the music but we don't like the way the people who created it lived their lives. But you can't separate the two. You have to try and understand the world in which they

[LUTE] Re: Ban the lute

2012-03-14 Thread Edward Mast
Very good point, Monica. Attending a concert/discussion/slide presentation recently by the duo Asteria, the issue of social context for the courtly love songs they sang was made quite clear. Seeing the areas where these songs were written and sung (Asteria travels to France annually to do

[LUTE] Re: Ban the lute

2012-03-14 Thread Alexei Nicolai
Dear List: I'm surprised no one has yet mentioned the difficulty Bach had with his parishoners over his arrangements of chorale preludes. From Christoph Wolff, Johann Sebastian Bach: The Learned Musician, p. 85: First, they reproved Bach for having hitherto made many curious variations in