We have modern examples of ensembles on similar instruments in the Venere
Quartet, the Kings Singers, and Piffaro, when they are on recorder.  For
mixed ensembles we can look to Piffaro, Baltimore Consort, and many
others.

Frankly, I find hour-long programs on similar ensembles deadly boreing,
much prefer the varyance of a mixed ensemble.

Voices, even ones that blend well, still have individual characteristics
ones mind can pick out.  I recall working with one composers Missa, very
polyphonic for voice.  I had prepared a piano score from the open vocal
score as we were blessed with a piano and player that week, 5vv with the
inner parts doing a lot of crossing, I wasnt sure my rendition would prove
suitable for our pianist, but she proved up to the task.

Sadly the polyphony got lost in the piano, and revealed the masterpiece
for voice was deadly dull on piano, basically one chord for most of 32
bars.
--
Dana S Emery



To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

Reply via email to