Re: Seeking advice for 4th course

2004-03-07 Thread David Cassetti
Thanks for all the responses - very helpful. I ended up trying carbon fiber (Savarez Alliance) for the 4th course (0.69mm, 2.4 kg tension), and am happy that the intonation issue is resolved, and the tone is better. It took about 5 days for the string to remain in tune overnight. -- David

Re: Seeking advice for 4th course

2004-02-18 Thread LGS-Europe
> I have an 8-course ren. lute, 570 cm string length 1st course g' (using > a'=415 as a reference), and tend to play mostly 6-course early ren. > music. I'm using nylon for the upper courses which results in a tension > of 3 kg for the chanterelle and 2.1 kg per string for the 2nd and 3rd > courses

Re: R: Seeking advice for 4th course

2004-02-18 Thread Edward Martin
I agree with Francesco and Thomas. I have tried almost every imaginable string, but I keep coming back to gut, as it is the best sounding string, without question. I used to use carbon, but in my opinion, it is a very cold, shrill sounding string. The good part about carbon is that it is incr

R: R: Seeking advice for 4th course

2004-02-18 Thread Francesco Tribioli
> > My teacher says that if you want longevity, use carbon. > > But if you want a good sound my hear says: definetively use > > gut. 8^) > > Francesco > And a modicum of masochism... > RT Not at all! I'm very happy with gut. My 3 lutes and my baroque guitar mounted gut strings from the be

Re: R: Seeking advice for 4th course

2004-02-18 Thread Roman Turovsky
>> My teacher says that if you want longevity, use carbon. > But if you want a good sound my hear says: definetively use gut. 8^) > Francesco And a modicum of masochism... RT

Re: Seeking advice for 4th course

2004-02-18 Thread Thomas Schall
But Carbon sounds *too* bright. It's good for instruments with weeknesses but gut instruments deserve better strings ... Am Mit, 2004-02-18 um 23.08 schrieb Herbert Ward: > My teacher says that if you want longevity, use carbon. -- Thomas Schall Niederhofheimer Weg 3 D-65843 Sulzbach 06196/

R: Seeking advice for 4th course

2004-02-18 Thread Francesco Tribioli
> My teacher says that if you want longevity, use carbon. > But if you want a good sound my hear says: definetively use gut. 8^) Francesco

Re: Seeking advice for 4th course

2004-02-18 Thread James A Stimson
net" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> et> cc: Su

Re: Seeking advice for 4th course

2004-02-18 Thread Thomas Schall
That doesn't meet my experience. I am using Nylgut for a fairly long time and made rather good experience regarding durability. My opinion: Nylgut is regarding sound and playability the best available at the moment apart from the one or the other gut string and is a good compromise between durabil

Re: Seeking advice for 4th course

2004-02-18 Thread Herbert Ward
My teacher says that if you want longevity, use carbon.

Re: Seeking advice for 4th course

2004-02-18 Thread Roman Turovsky
ps. Nylgut's niceties only last 2-3 weeks. After that it goes dead. RT >> I think a thinner string is required with adequate tension, but don't >> have any experience with gut, nylgut, carbon, etc. > I use carbon on 4 upper courses, happily. > RT > >

Re: Seeking advice for 4th course

2004-02-18 Thread Herbert Ward
The guys who sell lute strings are expert at this sort of thing (knowing, for example, what's actually available). Call several of them on the telephone and find one that seems knowledgeable and friendly. One list of retailers is at http://www.unm.edu/~ctdbach/music/lute_strings.html A little wo

Re: Seeking advice for 4th course

2004-02-18 Thread Roman Turovsky
> I think a thinner string is required with adequate tension, but don't > have any experience with gut, nylgut, carbon, etc. I use carbon on 4 upper courses, happily. RT

Seeking advice for 4th course

2004-02-18 Thread David Cassetti
Hi, all I have an 8-course ren. lute, 570 cm string length 1st course g' (using a'=415 as a reference), and tend to play mostly 6-course early ren. music. I'm using nylon for the upper courses which results in a tension of 3 kg for the chanterelle and 2.1 kg per string for the 2nd and 3rd cour