Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-11-24 Thread Gary
Andrew Daviel wrote: I have had a ticket open with Proxim for months, but nothing useful yet. There was a suggestions to disable unique SSIDs. I forgot to ask as it didn't occur to me before. Are any of your SSIDs hidden? I don't recall the strange terminology used by Proxim's web UI but it

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-11-04 Thread Kalle Valo
ext Andrew Daviel [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: On Fri, 22 Aug 2008, Kalle Valo wrote: First of all, sorry for taking so long. I was on vacation and had some urgent things to do first. The capture data is really helpful, thanks a lot for that. I'm looking at them right now. Did you ever find

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-11-03 Thread Andrew Daviel
On Fri, 17 Oct 2008, Gary wrote: I know it's difficult to do in a production environment but have you experimented with different AP firmware revisions? 3.4.0 is still very solid but some of the interim releases between there and 3.7 broke more than it fixed. I'm not on any of their announce

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-10-21 Thread Andrew Daviel
On Fri, 22 Aug 2008, Kalle Valo wrote: First of all, sorry for taking so long. I was on vacation and had some urgent things to do first. The capture data is really helpful, thanks a lot for that. I'm looking at them right now. Did you ever find anything ? I still have the problem, after a

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-10-17 Thread Gary
Andrew Daviel wrote: my problem is that the WiFi eats power talking to the Proxim APs at work, as if Power Save mode were not enabled I know it's difficult to do in a production environment but have you experimented with different AP firmware revisions? 3.4.0 is still very solid but some of

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-10-15 Thread Andrew Daviel
On Wed, 17 Sep 2008, Gary wrote: On Sun, Sep 14, 2008 at 11:42 AM, Andrew Daviel wrote: measuring the battery current and setting up an AP4000 Can I assume this is a Proxim AP? The 700s may be found for a fair price these days and use the same chipsets and firmware. Of course, the

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-10-15 Thread Gary
Andrew Daviel wrote: I was measuring the battery current directly: http://andrew.triumf.ca/andrew/photos/100_0536.JPG That isn't a 3rd party battery is it? ___ maemo-users mailing list maemo-users@maemo.org

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-10-15 Thread Andrew Daviel
On Wed, 15 Oct 2008, Gary wrote: Andrew Daviel wrote: I was measuring the battery current directly: http://andrew.triumf.ca/andrew/photos/100_0536.JPG That isn't a 3rd party battery is it? Yes. The original Nokia one failed (I think the clips might have fatigued due to vibration in the

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-10-15 Thread Gary
Andrew Daviel wrote: Meantime after trying several local stores for an OEM one I found this clone which has worked nicely ever since. I ask because the only time I had battery issues was when I'd installed one of the early canola betas. It seemed like it had some background networking task

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-10-15 Thread Andrew Daviel
On Wed, 15 Oct 2008, Gary wrote: Andrew Daviel wrote: Meantime after trying several local stores for an OEM one I found this clone which has worked nicely ever since. I ask because the only time I had battery issues was when I'd installed one of the early canola betas. It seemed like it

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-09-17 Thread Gary
On Sun, Sep 14, 2008 at 11:42 AM, Andrew Daviel wrote: measuring the battery current and setting up an AP4000 at home is a bit more time consuming. Can I assume this is a Proxim AP? The 700s may be found for a fair price these days and use the same chipsets and firmware. Of course, the

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-09-14 Thread Andrew Daviel
On Fri, 22 Aug 2008, Kalle Valo wrote: I have placed some capture data on my server at http://andrew.triumf.ca/reqauth/PSM/ (password test/test to keep out robots and the clueless) First of all, sorry for taking so long. I was on vacation and had some urgent things to do first. The capture

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-08-08 Thread Andrew Daviel
On Tue, 5 Aug 2008, David Grau Serra wrote: Capture files on http://andrew.triumf.ca/reqauth/PSM/ It is necessary an user and a pass =-O the user = passwd = test, which is in the challenge. I had creted that directory for a demo of something else, and placed the capture files there just

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-08-06 Thread Alejandro López
Hi, Andrew Daviel wrote: With beacon SSID enabled on triumf but disabled on test - 10mA With beacon SSID enabled on triumf and enabled on test - 100mA With beacon SSID disabled on triumf but enabled on test - 100mA With beacon SSID disabled on triumf and disabled on test - 10mA (The N810 is

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-08-05 Thread Andrew Daviel
I have done some more tests with the Proxim AP4000, but I still cannot see a problem in the protocol. I have put an ammeter inline between the N810 battery and connectors so I can see the current consumption in real time - it is pretty impressive that it can draw virtually no current at all

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-08-05 Thread David Grau Serra
Capture files on http://andrew.triumf.ca/reqauth/PSM/ It is necessary an user and a pass =-O ___ maemo-users mailing list maemo-users@maemo.org https://lists.maemo.org/mailman/listinfo/maemo-users

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-30 Thread Andrew Daviel
On Sat, 26 Jul 2008, Andrew Daviel wrote: I may be able to get a spare Proxim AP to take home. There's a limit on what I can mess with on our production WLAN :-7, and I'd have a less noisy environment. Well, I got one. The power consumption seems normal (i.e. PS mode seems to be working). I

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-26 Thread Andrew Daviel
On Thu, 24 Jul 2008, Kalle Valo wrote: (packets from N810 captured with airodump-ng show as malformed) Usually missing FCS causes this. There's a setting in Wireshark under IEEE 802.11 to enable and disable FCS calculation. Try reverting that option. Yes. Edit/Preferences/Protocols/IEEE

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-23 Thread Andrew Daviel
I opened a ticket with Proxim. They suggest turning off SSID broadcast and see if that reduces the battery use. Sounds like b/s to me, but I may be wrong. If I try that at home, I have to mark the connection as hidden otherwise I can't select it to connect to, and I suspect it would annoy

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-23 Thread Kalle Valo
ext John Holmblad [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Kalle. Hi John, thanks for sharing your deep, if sleep deprived, insights re 802.11 power management. I'm glad that it was helpful. I have read them out of both general interest in the workings of 802.11 but also as a result of the fact that

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-23 Thread Kalle Valo
ext Frederic Crozat [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Why is PSM so fragile then? Since I can't sleep (jet lag, argh), I'll write a bit about this. snip wow, thanks for the detail explanations. I kind of better understand PSM issues. Excellent. A first bug was found in ralink proprietary driver

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-23 Thread Kalle Valo
ext Andrew Daviel [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Excellent writeup, thanks :-) You welcome. So, what devices apart from the Nokia tablets use PSM ? Nokia phones (N95, N81 etc) use WLAN PSM. They might even have more aggressive PSM tablets have. iPhone ? I once (like a year ago) played with an

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-23 Thread Frederic Crozat
On Wed, Jul 23, 2008 at 9:43 PM, Kalle Valo [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: ext Frederic Crozat [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: But what I could do is to analyse the problem myself. It would take only an hour or two, including writing a small report about the problem which I can send everyone interested

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-23 Thread John Holmblad
Andrew, after thinking about Kalle's explanation of PSM, and as the owner of a UTStarcom Windows Mobile handset (Verizon Wireless XV6700) that supports both EVDO and 802.11b, I have to conclude that, The UTS XV6700 does not do a satisfactory job with respect to PSM. My conclusion here is

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-22 Thread Andrew Daviel
On Mon, 21 Jul 2008, Andrew Daviel wrote: Is there anything for the tablets that can log wireless traffic in enough detail to show whether PSM is working ? airodump-ng ?? Should have tried before posting. I have a couple of capture files made with airodump-ng --beacons, which I can view in

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-21 Thread Kalle Valo
ext Andrew Daviel [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: On Mon, Apr 21, 2008 at 4:58 PM, Eero Tamminen [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: One possibility is a WLAN AP with broken power management I recently noticed that my tablet battery runs down faster at work than at home, with the WiFi enabled but

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-21 Thread Andrew Daviel
On Mon, 21 Jul 2008, Kalle Valo wrote: I recently noticed that my tablet battery runs down faster at work than at home, with the WiFi enabled but otherwise sitting idle (12%/hour vs 1%/hour). What do you mean by 12%/hour? That the battery will run out in eight hours? I guess. I was using

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-21 Thread Kalle Valo
ext Frederic Crozat [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: What power-management issues have you seen affecting battery life ? I think it is usually caused by interoperability deficiency between 770/n8x0 and some routers wifi chipset regarding PSM (Power Saving Management) part of wifi specification.

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-21 Thread Kalle Valo
ext Andrew Daviel [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: On Mon, 21 Jul 2008, Kalle Valo wrote: I recently noticed that my tablet battery runs down faster at work than at home, with the WiFi enabled but otherwise sitting idle (12%/hour vs 1%/hour). What do you mean by 12%/hour? That the battery will

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-21 Thread Frederic Crozat
On Mon, Jul 21, 2008 at 11:39 AM, Kalle Valo [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: ext Frederic Crozat [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: What power-management issues have you seen affecting battery life ? I think it is usually caused by interoperability deficiency between 770/n8x0 and some routers wifi chipset

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-21 Thread Andrew Daviel
Excellent writeup, thanks :-) So, what devices apart from the Nokia tablets use PSM ? iPhone ? Palm ? Windows Mobile devices like the UTstarcom PocketPC ? I opened a ticket with Proxim; not sure if our contract includes support but maybe I'll get a reply. Is there anything for the tablets

Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-20 Thread Andrew Daviel
On Mon, Apr 21, 2008 at 4:58 PM, Eero Tamminen [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: One possibility is a WLAN AP with broken power management I recently noticed that my tablet battery runs down faster at work than at home, with the WiFi enabled but otherwise sitting idle (12%/hour vs 1%/hour). I

Re: Power consumption and WLAN APs

2008-07-20 Thread Frederic Crozat
On Sun, Jul 20, 2008 at 10:27 PM, Andrew Daviel [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Mon, Apr 21, 2008 at 4:58 PM, Eero Tamminen [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: One possibility is a WLAN AP with broken power management I recently noticed that my tablet battery runs down faster at work than at home, with