Re: [E] Re: the v2 commit algorithm

2020-10-20 Thread Steve Loughran
wise to change the default behavior for released versions > of Hadoop? Should this be limited to > trunk? > > Thanks, > -Eric Payne > > > On Wednesday, September 23, 2020, 2:16:14 PM CDT, Jim Brennan > wrote: > > I replied in the Jira. The speed up provided b

Re: [E] Re: the v2 commit algorithm

2020-09-24 Thread epa...@apache.org
? Thanks, -Eric Payne On Wednesday, September 23, 2020, 2:16:14 PM CDT, Jim Brennan wrote: I replied in the Jira.  The speed up provided by the v2 commit algorithm is very important to us at Verizon Media (Yahoo).  Please do not remove it. I referred to this comment from Jason Lowe on the original

Re: [E] Re: the v2 commit algorithm

2020-09-24 Thread Steve Loughran
On Wed, 23 Sep 2020 at 20:16, Jim Brennan wrote: > I replied in the Jira. The speed up provided by the v2 commit algorithm > is very important to us at Verizon Media (Yahoo). Please do not remove it. > I referred to this comment from Jason Lowe on the original Jira:

Re: the v2 commit algorithm

2020-09-24 Thread Steve Loughran
e got a PR up to completely remove the v2 commit algorithm >> >> https://github.com/apache/hadoop/pull/2320 >> >> That may seem overkill, but while *we* know there's a small window of risk >> (task attempt 1 failing partway through a nonatomic commit), that's n

Re: [E] Re: the v2 commit algorithm

2020-09-23 Thread Jim Brennan
I replied in the Jira. The speed up provided by the v2 commit algorithm is very important to us at Verizon Media (Yahoo). Please do not remove it. I referred to this comment from Jason Lowe on the original Jira: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/MAPREDUCE-4815?focusedCommentId=14271115&

Re: the v2 commit algorithm

2020-09-23 Thread Igor Dvorzhak
What will be the solution for object stores to have fast and correct commit algorithms? On Wed, Sep 23, 2020 at 11:42 AM Steve Loughran wrote: > I've got a PR up to completely remove the v2 commit algorithm > > https://github.com/apache/hadoop/pull/2320 > > That may seem ove

the v2 commit algorithm

2020-09-23 Thread Steve Loughran
I've got a PR up to completely remove the v2 commit algorithm https://github.com/apache/hadoop/pull/2320 That may seem overkill, but while *we* know there's a small window of risk (task attempt 1 failing partway through a nonatomic commit), that's not known/appreciated by oth