Re: wgo url policy

2006-07-21 Thread Thomas Wood
Dave Neary wrote: > [...] >> - I suggest no extensions to file names, this way resources can act as >> containers >> for example: >> www.gnome.org/start and www.gnome.org/start/2.14 >> instead of >> www.gnome.org/start.html and www.gnome.org/start/2.14 >> > > I don't think this is really an i

Re: wgo url policy

2006-07-14 Thread John Hwang
> Like Jeff, I also tend to think that query string approach is the > cleanest. It implies it's the same resource with a different parameter, > that is "display language". Can be problematic though with some CMS > engines and usual URL rewriting rules (that for example would > translate /foo/bar/ba

Re: wgo url policy

2006-07-14 Thread Gergely Nagy
On Fri, 2006-07-14 at 00:24 +1000, Jeff Waugh wrote: > > > > > Minimal redundancy > > > Avoid multiple URLs for a given page. Currently both http://gnome.org > > > and http://www.gnome.org exist. I suggest to forward all gnome.org > > > access to www.gnome.org. Are there any duplicate pages on wg

Re: wgo url policy

2006-07-13 Thread Jeff Waugh
> > Minimal redundancy > > Avoid multiple URLs for a given page. Currently both http://gnome.org > > and http://www.gnome.org exist. I suggest to forward all gnome.org > > access to www.gnome.org. Are there any duplicate pages on wgo now? > > These are not duplicate pages, they are aliases. gnom

Re: wgo url policy

2006-07-13 Thread Dave Neary
Hi, Gergely Nagy wrote: > Minimal redundancy > Avoid multiple URLs for a given page. Currently both http://gnome.org > and http://www.gnome.org exist. I suggest to forward all gnome.org > access to www.gnome.org. Are there any duplicate pages on wgo now? These are not duplicate pages, they are a

wgo url policy

2006-07-13 Thread Gergely Nagy
First of all, great work guys, Quim's list of goals, Sigurd's Policy page and Christian's Localization document are Excellent! (all in live.gnome.org) I would like to start discussion on our URL policies. Requirements - persistent - support site partitioning - minimal redundancy - friendly urls -