******************** POSTING RULES & NOTES ********************
#1 YOU MUST clip all extraneous text when replying to a message.
#2 This mail-list, like most, is publicly & permanently archived.
#3 Subscribe and post under an alias if #2 is a concern.
*****************************************************************
NY Times Op-Ed, Feb. 22, 2018
Remembering the White Rose
By RICHARD HUROWITZ
Seventy-five years ago Thursday, a group of young German idealists,
students who had dared to speak out against the Nazis, were executed by
the regime they had defied. Like a flickering flame in the darkness, the
White Rose, as its members called themselves, is an inspiring group that
never lost its courage — and a frightening reminder of how rare such
heroes are.
The group’s founder, Hans Scholl, and his sister Sophie grew up outside
Munich. Their father instilled in them a strong moral compass and a
religious worldview. Like many his age, Hans joined the Hitler Youth.
But he began to have doubts almost immediately: The Nazis did not allow
him to sing certain songs, fly certain flags or read Stefan Zweig, his
favorite author. He earned a spot as a flag-bearer at the annual
Nuremberg Rally and returned disturbed at what he had seen.
Hans wanted to become a doctor, and when he was drafted he was posted as
a medic in France. After a tour of duty, he went back to the University
of Munich to continue his medical studies. Sophie soon joined him as an
undergraduate. Hans read widely — Plato, Socrates, St. Augustine and
Pascal — and decorated his dorm room with Modernist French art. He
attracted a circle of like-minded students: Alexander Schmorell, the son
of a doctor; Christoph Probst, a young father of two toddlers; and Willi
Graf, a thoughtful introvert. They soon found an intellectual mentor in
Kurt Huber, a professor of philosophy and ardent believer in liberal
democracy.
In the summer of 1942, Hans and his friends — inspired by the sermons of
the anti-Nazi bishop of Münster — began to distribute typewritten
leaflets denouncing the regime. Their language was incandescent. “Every
honest German today is ashamed of his government,” Hans wrote, a
government that committed “the most horrible of crimes — crimes that
indefinitely outdistance every human measure.” The members of the White
Rose declared that all those who stood by were complicit and implored
all citizens to engage in “passive resistance” to the Nazi state.
The White Rose also addressed the atrocities against Jews. Schmorell and
Hans wrote in the group’s second leaflet: “Here we see the most
frightful crime against human dignity, a crime that is unparalleled in
the whole of history. For Jews, too, are human beings.” No punches were
pulled even when it came to the Führer: “Every word that comes from
Hitler’s mouth is a lie.” Sprinkled with erudite references to Goethe,
Aristotle, Schiller, Ecclesiastes, Lao Tzu and others, the leaflets
concluded with a plea to support the White Rose by circulating them. “We
will not be silent,” ended the fourth. “We are your bad conscience. The
White Rose will not leave you in peace.”
The leaflets appeared in mailboxes and phone booths between late June
and mid-July 1942 and spread to sympathetic students in Frankfurt,
Hamburg, Berlin and Vienna. Then they stopped as Hans, Schmorell, Graf
and Probst were shipped east on a day’s notice to the Russian front,
where the Germans were bogged down. Yet Hans fought back against the
Nazis with acts of simple humanity even as he approached the front. On
his train to Russia, he saw a young Jewish girl doing hard labor,
wearing the yellow Star of David mandated by the Nazis. Running from his
transport, Hans handed her a chocolate bar from his rations — and a
daisy for her hair.
After returning from the front, Hans and the others released two more
leaflets warning that with the loss at Stalingrad, German defeat was
inevitable. Declaring the preciousness of individual rights, the
leaflets asked, “Are we forever to be a nation that is hated and
rejected by all mankind?” Hans, Schmorell and Graf sneaked out at night
and painted signs reading “Down with Hitler,” “Freedom” and other
slogans on the main boulevard in Munich.
Then on Feb. 18, 1943, Hans and Sophie decided to distribute leaflets at
the university, leaving stacks in corridors. As they started to leave,
Sophie noticed that there were more copies in their suitcase and headed
to the top of the stairs, which overlooked an atrium. She hurled the
remaining leaflets in the air and watched as they drifted down the
stairwell.
The maintenance man, Jakob Schmid, an ardent Nazi, was watching. He
immediately locked the doors and notified the authorities. The siblings
were hauled to the Wittelsbach Palace, the headquarters of the Gestapo.
Soon after, Probst, whose wife had had a third child weeks before, was
also arrested. The three were interrogated for several days, but they
refused to implicate others.
All three were found of guilty of high treason and sentenced to death.
Within hours, they were executed by guillotine. Before Hans placed his
head upon the block, his final words echoed through the prison: “Long
live freedom.” Within weeks, the other core members of the White Rose
were apprehended and executed.
The story of the White Rose did make it to the front, where it inspired
soldiers who were opposed to the regime. But the hope that its members
had of inspiring their fellow citizens was not fulfilled. Their call was
ignored.
“They did not seek martyrdom in the name of any extraordinary idea,”
Inge Scholl recalled in her memoir of her siblings and White Rose
comrades. “They wanted to make it possible for people like you and me to
live in a humane society.” We are far from the darkness of fascism, but
we do ourselves a service by remembering the sad but noble story of
these beautiful souls on the anniversary of their tragic sacrifice.
Richard Hurowitz is an investor, writer and the publisher of The
Octavian Report, a quarterly magazine of ideas.
_________________________________________________________
Full posting guidelines at: http://www.marxmail.org/sub.htm
Set your options at:
http://lists.csbs.utah.edu/options/marxism/archive%40mail-archive.com