In America’s healthcare reform debate, there is no greater whipping boy than
the National Health Service (NHS,) Britain’s healthcare system. The NHS is
being used as an example of the “failed Socialist” model of healthcare. FOX
host Glenn Beck took some shots at the NHS, apparently forgetting his own
nightmare journey when he received subpar care in an American hospital.
Republican Senator Chuck Grassley told a radio station last week that
“countries that have government-run health care” would not have given Senator
Edward Kennedy, who suffers from a brain tumor, the same kind of care as in the
U.S. because he is too old. And most impressively, FOX News’s treasure, Neil
Cavuto, even claimed universal healthcare is a terrorism recruitment tool.
Seriously.
Conservative hosts and politicians alike must have been overcome with joy when
they finally secured a Conservative British politician who was willing to bad
mouth the NHS, which remains extraordinarily popular in Britain. Daniel Hannan
previously sat as an Independent after having been expelled from the European
People’s Party. Hannan is most famous for opposing the European Union and
praising Iceland’s “economic miracle” prior to the country’s titanic crash in
2008. It was probably that stellar resume that first caught the eye of FOX
News, which couldn’t secure the microphone to his lapel fast enough.
These kinds of attacks on the NHS aren’t unusual or new, but what is unique is
the British response this time to the mad attacks on their healthcare system.
British citizens — particularly tech savvy residents — are fighting back on
Twitter. The top trending topics after Hannan’s FOX declarations included
#welovetheNHS and #NHS. British Twitterers boasted ‘I Heart NHS’ avatars
designed by Twibbon, a group that spreads awareness about causes by overlaying
an image onto supporters’ Twitter profile avatars. The Twibbon team says during
our interview that the response to the ‘I Heart NHS’ design has been
“magnificent.” They add, “In the UK, people often talk about political apathy
and show concern over disappointing voting turnouts. What everyone has shown
over the last few days is a testament to the power of social networking, and
Twitter in particular, not only to unite people in solidarity, but also to
initiate global conversations
at grassroots level.”
Graham Linehan, the man behind the #welovetheNHS tag, tells me he was motivated
by FOX’s irresponsible coverage of the healthcare reform debate.
I think that the way that FOX News has been raising the temperature of the
health care debate over there is one of the most reckless and cynical things I
have ever seen. It’s just mindblowing to me. It’s also infruriating the way
they change their coverage of the UK according to their needs. So when they
wanted a partner to legitimise an illegal and ill-thought-out war, the UK was
the best country in the world. Now that their needs are different, they attack
the UK as ‘Socialist’. It’s breathtaking, how little shame they have.
What really inspired Linehan to do something was when Investor’s Business Daily
published an editorial claiming Steven Hawking “wouldn’t have a chance in the
U.K., where the National Health Service would say the life of this brilliant
man, because of his physical handicaps, is essentially worthless.” Of course,
the claim is absurd as Hawking stated later, pointing out that he would not be
alive today if it hadn’t been for the NHS.
Where other British citizens saw gross lies, exaggerations, and frustrating
half-truths, Linehan saw a “golden opportunity to kickstart a campaign to
redress the balance a little bit.” He linked to the Hawking article and the
#welovetheNHS hashtag was born. “I thought it might pick up steam once people
saw the ridiculousness of that story, but I had no idea how big it would
become. Three days now, and we’re still trending,” says Linehan.
The online response to the We Love the NHS campaign is overwhelming. “NHS Saved
my life as a 19 year old naive lad!” writes one Brit. ”Saved my life, saved my
wife’s life, beat my brother-in-law’s cancer and embodies a compassionate
civilized ideal #welovetheNHS,” writes one more. The movement now includes some
of Britain’s most powerful leaders, including Prime Minister Gordon Brown, who
Tweeted “NHS often makes the difference between pain and comfort, despair and
hope, life and death. Thanks for always being there #welovetheNHS.”
British newspapers, politicians, and medics are rushing into the debate partly
to defend the NHS and partly to gain some kind of political leverage. Labor
hoped to embarrass David Cameron by challenging him to disown the Hannan
comments, which he did. “Nobody should be in any doubt, for the Conservative
Party, the NHS is the number one priority,” said Cameron to Sky News.
The British newspaper, Daily Mirror, has started calling America ”the land of
the fee” because of the way patients are forced to pay for medical services.
Senior figures in British healthcare are also frustrated at the portrayal of
the NHS. Mike Hobday, of Macmillan Cancer Support, stated: “We are really
furious at the way in which the NHS, which is the best healthcare system
around, is being denigrated by a group of people who clearly don’t have the
first idea about how it works.”
“The NHS does a damn fine job,” says president of the UK Faculty of Public
Health, Dr. Alan Maryon-Davis. “These claims are complete and utter rubbish…The
horrific thing about the American system is that there are tens of millions of
people without health insurance. We spend less on health in terms of GDP than
America but if you look at health indices, especially for life expectancy, we
have better figures than they do in America,” he adds.
The nexus of the Internet makes the dissemination of disinformation difficult.
Such interconnectedness means the lie of “dangerous Socialized medicine” cannot
sustain itself when Brits of all ages and backgrounds shout to the rafters that
they love the NHS, and are here to defend it.
http://tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com/talk/blogs/erica/2009/08/stephen-hawking-likes-his-deat.php?ref=recdc
________________________________________________
YOU MUST clip all extraneous text when replying to a message.
Send list submissions to: Marxism@lists.econ.utah.edu
Set your options at:
http://lists.econ.utah.edu/mailman/options/marxism/archive%40mail-archive.com
