CB: Commodithy production does not arise, as you say, "on the basis of a
certain stage in the development of the productive forces."
WL: Really.
This is what I wrote and you quote:
"bourgeois property does not arise on the basis of private property but
rather on the basis of a certain stage
WL: This is not true because bourgeois property does not arise on the basis
of
private property but rather on the basis of a certain stage in the
development
of the productive forces - commodity production, that compels a change in
the
form of private property. Private property exists before bou