Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-30 Thread Mountain Man
--R wrote: > If we take this to BannedLite... It's there - over at BannedLite. Tell us the story over there. thanks mao ___ http://www.okiebenz.com For new and used parts go to www.okiebenz.com To search list archives http://www.okiebenz.com/archive/ To Unsubs

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-30 Thread Rich Thomas
If we take this to BannedLite I can relate my experience with hard-"working" union members at a IH truck plant about 30 yr ago. I doubt if much has changed since then. --R Allan Streib wrote: "Tom Hargrave" said: A 30 year option to retire for lost career opportunities, worn out body j

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-30 Thread Tom Hargrave
Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM pm7...@comcast.net said: > Misleading. They do not HAVE to retire, they simply max their pensions > after 30 years. The pension is part of their compensation package, they > negotiated it and the management gave it to them. Did you tak

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-30 Thread Allan Streib
"Mitch Haley" said: > Her husband intends to keep working until his employer (a major university) > throws him out the door at age 70 My dad did that. He was a career research chemist. Retired at 70. Died at 72. Allan -- 1983 300D ___ http://www.okiebe

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-30 Thread Allan Streib
There are lots of jobs where you "work" for 8 hours, with minimal breaks, on your feet the whole time. Many of them command low wages and poor benefits. I'm not sure how many directly compare to doing the *same* thing over and over, hundreds of times a day on an assembly line; each job has its un

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-30 Thread Mitch Haley
Tom Hargrave wrote: Nope, the auto workers have a 30 year retirement plan. For example, my Wife is eligible to retire at the age of 54 - that's 11 years short of Medicare. A friend of mine retired from county government (welfare caseworker) after 20 years at the age of 37 or 38. She started th

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-30 Thread OK Don
Sounds a lot like my wife's nursing jobs - yes they schedled breaks, not you didn't have time to take them. She ate lunch in 15 to 20 minutes and got to pee during the "1 hour" lunch break, then back at it. She did that for 35 years, with breaks to have kids. On Tue, Dec 30, 2008 at 10:39 AM, Alla

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-30 Thread Allan Streib
"Tom Hargrave" said: > A 30 year option to retire for lost career opportunities, worn out body > joints from repetitive motion (Wife, her sister & brother in-law have had > carpel tunnel release surgery - wife has bad knees from one job she did for > 6 years), very strict work schedule and a job

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-30 Thread Allan Streib
pm7...@comcast.net said: > Misleading. They do not HAVE to retire, they simply max their pensions > after 30 years. The pension is part of their compensation package, they > negotiated it and the management gave it to them. Did you take all your > employer offered you last year? I did! I don'

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-30 Thread pm7088
-- Original message -- From: "Tom Hargrave" > I never stated that have to retire - in the last paragraph, I stated "the > option to retire". > > Also, the prospects of employment after retirement after working for the big > three are grim. I understand, the chan

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-30 Thread Curt Raymond
That retirement plan is part of the problem no? I get to retire when I decide my 401k has enough money in it, which I'm guessing is the 12th of never... -Curt Date: Mon, 29 Dec 2008 20:44:44 -0600 From: "Tom Hargrave" Subject: Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM To: "'Mercedes Disc

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-30 Thread Tom Hargrave
inal Message- From: mercedes-boun...@okiebenz.com [mailto:mercedes-boun...@okiebenz.com] On Behalf Of pm7...@comcast.net Sent: Tuesday, December 30, 2008 7:38 AM To: Mercedes Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM Misleading. They do not HAVE to retire, they simply max their pensions afte

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-30 Thread pm7088
Misleading. They do not HAVE to retire, they simply max their pensions after 30 years. The pension is part of their compensation package, they negotiated it and the management gave it to them. Did you take all your employer offered you last year? I did! If a UAW worker is smart, He/She leave

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-30 Thread Tom Hargrave
cedes-boun...@okiebenz.com] On Behalf Of Allan Streib Sent: Monday, December 29, 2008 8:58 PM To: Mercedes Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM "Tom Hargrave" writes: > Nope, the auto workers have a 30 year retirement plan. For example, my > Wife is eligible to retir

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-29 Thread Rich Thomas
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/30/business/30auto.html ___ http://www.okiebenz.com For new and used parts go to www.okiebenz.com To search list archives http://www.okiebenz.com/archive/ To Unsubscribe or change delivery options go to: http://okiebenz.com/mailm

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-29 Thread Allan Streib
"Tom Hargrave" writes: > Nope, the auto workers have a 30 year retirement plan. For example, my > Wife is eligible to retire at the age of 54 - that's 11 years short of > Medicare. If she had gone to work for Chrysler when she was 18, as > many did in states like Michigan, she would have retired

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-29 Thread Tom Hargrave
lan Streib Sent: Monday, December 29, 2008 8:30 PM To: Mercedes Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM "Tom Hargrave" writes: > The issue is that each GM worker is supporting the medical benefits of > 1.6 retirees & their families. Um wait, retired workers would be o

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-29 Thread Wilton Strickland
Medicare at 65 years. Wilton - Original Message - From: "Allan Streib" To: "Mercedes Discussion List" Sent: Monday, December 29, 2008 9:30 PM Subject: Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM > "Tom Hargrave" writes: > > > The issue is that each GM wo

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-29 Thread Tom Hargrave
oun...@okiebenz.com] On Behalf Of Allan Streib Sent: Monday, December 29, 2008 8:15 PM To: Mercedes Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM "OK Don" writes: > I wonder if Toyota provides a living retirement package, and what > their profit margin will look like after they

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-29 Thread Allan Streib
"Tom Hargrave" writes: > The issue is that each GM worker is supporting the medical benefits of > 1.6 retirees & their families. Um wait, retired workers would be on Medicare no? Allan -- 1983 300D ___ http://www.okiebenz.com For new and used parts go to ww

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-29 Thread Tom Hargrave
8 7:35 PM To: Mercedes Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM I wonder if Toyota provides a living retirement package, and what their profit margin will look like after they have a generation of retired workers to provide for? On Mon, Dec 29, 2008 at 7:24 PM, Allen Sawyer wrote: > It h

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-29 Thread Allan Streib
"OK Don" writes: > I wonder if Toyota provides a living retirement package, and what > their profit margin will look like after they have a generation of > retired workers to provide for? If they're smart they have 401k plans or whatever, that they fund at some base amount, and to which employee

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-29 Thread OK Don
I wonder if Toyota provides a living retirement package, and what their profit margin will look like after they have a generation of retired workers to provide for? On Mon, Dec 29, 2008 at 7:24 PM, Allen Sawyer wrote: > It has been published several times that last year, both Toyota and GM > pr

[MBZ] Toyota vs GM

2008-12-29 Thread Allen Sawyer
It has been published several times that last year, both Toyota and GM produced the same number of vehicles, something like seventeen million, but Toyota's profit was 17 billion, and GM had a loss of 39 billion. Several people are going to have make some kind of sacrifice to achieve equity. I

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs. GM was Re: Anyone Have Carfax?

2006-08-05 Thread David Brodbeck
Steve MacSween wrote: > Creditors can bring a smaller firm to its knees, but when you are playing to > the stakes and on the scale GM operates, worldwide, it would be an > administrative nightmare and no one is in a position to see a net benefit > from pulling the plug on them. > Although I do

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs. GM was Re: Anyone Have Carfax?

2006-08-05 Thread Steve MacSween
on 8/4/06 5:48 PM, Rick Knoble at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: >> Unfortunately, though I agree with you about their deserving to go the way >> of the dodo, the plain fact is that they are simply too huge to die. You >> cannot put a company that large out of business except by government >> action, >>

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs. GM was Re: Anyone Have Carfax?

2006-08-05 Thread Peter Frederick
Well, if they don't learn to build decent automobiles, even that won't help! The real problem is the management culture. Peter

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs. GM was Re: Anyone Have Carfax?

2006-08-05 Thread David Brodbeck
Steve MacSween wrote: > Unfortunately, though I agree with you about their deserving to go the way > of the dodo, the plain fact is that they are simply too huge to die. You > cannot put a company that large out of business except by government action, > not to my knowledge anyway. > GM will do

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs. GM was Re: Anyone Have Carfax?

2006-08-04 Thread Rick Knoble
Unfortunately, though I agree with you about their deserving to go the way of the dodo, the plain fact is that they are simply too huge to die. You cannot put a company that large out of business except by government action, not to my knowledge anyway. Ever hear of Bethlehem Steel? LTV Steel

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs. GM was Re: Anyone Have Carfax?

2006-08-04 Thread Steve MacSween
Unfortunately, though I agree with you about their deserving to go the way of the dodo, the plain fact is that they are simply too huge to die. You cannot put a company that large out of business except by government action, not to my knowledge anyway. I wager Ford will be the one to go. One of th

Re: [MBZ] Toyota vs. GM was Re: Anyone Have Carfax?

2006-08-04 Thread Jeff Zedic
Nothing can save GM. They have decades to build a better product and they've squandered every chance they got. And then t add lunacy to the mix,they've built their while "recovery" on their new SUV's Dumb dumb dumb! Jeff Zedic 87 300TD

[MBZ] Toyota vs. GM was Re: Anyone Have Carfax?

2006-08-04 Thread Rick Knoble
- Original Message - Remember that Toyota is poised to surpass GM as the largest automaker on the planet. Thats Toyota, Lexus and Scion vs Chevrolet, GMC, Buick, Pontiac, Cadillac, Hummer, Saab, and Saturn. Wasn't it also the crazy chairman of Toyota (could have been Honda) that sa