Re: [meteorite-list] Photo of a K-chondrite / Could this be one of the rarest meteorites found?

2009-11-18 Thread Greg Stanley
> Date: Wed, 18 Nov 2009 13:17:06 -0800 > From: meteorite...@gmail.com > To: meteorite-list@meteoritecentral.com > Subject: Re: [meteorite-list] Photo of a K-chondrite / Could this be one of > the rarest meteorites found? > > Hello Frank, All, > > The trouble with that example is t

Re: [meteorite-list] Photo of a K-chondrite / Could this be one of the rarest meteorites found?

2009-11-18 Thread Jason Utas
Hello Frank, All, The trouble with that example is that it really supports both viewpoints, due to its context. First and foremost, its type was extremely uncommon at the time (Eucrites are now rather commonplace), and second, there was very little available of both the type and of the given fall

Re: [meteorite-list] Photo of a K-chondrite / Could this be one of the rarest meteorites found?

2009-11-17 Thread Frank Cressy
  Hello all, Thought this might be of some interest concerning the rarest meteorite, at least from a historical viewpoint.  At the beginning of the Twentieth Century, Henry A. Ward thought Nobleborough (1823 Maine fall) was one of the rarest of the meteorites he owned.  At this time Ward owned

Re: [meteorite-list] Photo of a K-chondrite / Could this be one of the rarest meteorites found?

2009-11-17 Thread Richard Kowalski
K-chondrite / Could this be one of > the rarest meteorites found? > To: bernd.pa...@paulinet.de, meteorite-list@meteoritecentral.com > Date: Tuesday, November 17, 2009, 7:12 PM > Hi Bernd and list, > > Would this be one of the rarest meteorites ever found? If > not, what meteorit

Re: [meteorite-list] Photo of a K-chondrite / Could this be one of the rarest meteorites found?

2009-11-17 Thread Meteorites USA
Hey Jason, I agree with you, I'm just teasing you a bit... ;) You needn't defend your definition. The simplest point is that there is more than one factor involved in determining the rarity of a meteorite, or individual type. It can be all the above, and/or just one factor, as in your rare n

Re: [meteorite-list] Photo of a K-chondrite / Could this be one of the rarest meteorites found?

2009-11-17 Thread Jason Utas
Hola Eric, All, You're only talking about collector availability, which is a kind of skewed way of looking at things, in my opinion. I'm talking about rarity in the sense of how much of a given material is known, "material" being the term for meteoric matter of a given structure and chemical compos

Re: [meteorite-list] Photo of a K-chondrite / Could this be one of the rarest meteorites found?

2009-11-17 Thread Meteorites USA
Jason, list, Maybe I don't quite understand... ;) The size of an individual meteorite whether ungrouped or even a previously unknown type or new classification would not be the deciding factor in determining rarity at all would it? If of course you consider the major factor concerning rarity

Re: [meteorite-list] Photo of a K-chondrite / Could this be one of the rarest meteorites found?

2009-11-17 Thread Jason Utas
Hello Sonny, All, I've often thought about such a term - "the rarest meteorite." The rarest meteorite would of course be smallest ungrouped meteorite, for one could feasibly conceive of a 1-2g unique meteorite. When a new type is named, however, a hype generally surrounds it - rather like the oliv

Re: [meteorite-list] Photo of a K-chondrite / Could this be one of the rarest meteorites found?

2009-11-17 Thread wahlperry
Hi Bernd and list, Would this be one of the rarest meteorites ever found? If not, what meteorite would be? Thanks, Sonny -Original Message- From: bernd.pa...@paulinet.de To: Meteorite-list@meteoritecentral.com Sent: Tue, Nov 17, 2009 1:12 pm Subject: [meteorite-list] Photo of a K-ch