[Mikrotik] Hopefully a stupid question about VLANs

2011-06-17 Thread Jacob Heider
I wouldn't ask this, if I hadn't been burned by Juniper on this very issue. Anyone able to state definitively if RouterOS will support both vlan 1 (untagged) and higher number (tagged) traffic on the same interface? Cisco devices could care less, but for some reason, fully confirmed by Juniper

Re: [Mikrotik] Hopefully a stupid question about VLANs

2011-06-17 Thread Sam Tetherow
I don't know about terminating VLANs but I have set up a bandwidth shaper in bridge mode that handles several VLANs, including VLAN 1 on two NICs (Internal / External) On 6/17/11 11:39 AM, Jacob Heider wrote: I wouldn't ask this, if I hadn't been burned by Juniper on this very issue. Anyone

Re: [Mikrotik] Hopefully a stupid question about VLANs

2011-06-17 Thread Blake Covarrubias
No, ROS will not support untagged and tagged on the same layer 3 interface. -- Blake Covarrubias On Jun 17, 2011, at 9:39 AM, Jacob Heider wrote: I wouldn't ask this, if I hadn't been burned by Juniper on this very issue. Anyone able to state definitively if RouterOS will support both vlan 1

Re: [Mikrotik] Hopefully a stupid question about VLANs

2011-06-17 Thread Eric Merkel
://www.butchevans.com/mailman/listinfo/mikrotik Visit http://blog.butchevans.com/ for tutorials related to Mikrotik RouterOS -- next part -- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://www.butchevans.com/pipermail/mikrotik/attachments/20110617/4348797e/attachment.html

Re: [Mikrotik] Hopefully a stupid question about VLANs

2011-06-17 Thread Andrew Thrift
JunOS devices can do this, I have a large number of clients running these configurations. Juniper J Series, EX, MX and SRX devices. On 18/06/2011 4:39 a.m., Jacob Heider wrote: I wouldn't ask this, if I hadn't been burned by Juniper on this very issue. Anyone able to state definitively if

Re: [Mikrotik] Hopefully a stupid question about VLANs

2011-06-17 Thread Jacob Heider
Are you sure about that, Andrew? I went back and forth with JTAC and they told me definitively that their OS didn't support it, which certainly bore out what I was seeing. I was forced to use two connections from my router to my switch, one for VLAN 1, and one for the tagged traffic. This was

Re: [Mikrotik] Hopefully a stupid question about VLANs

2011-06-17 Thread Andrew Thrift
Yes I am certain. Config format is: ge-0/1/0 { description L2 Aggregation; unit 0 { family ethernet-switching { port-mode trunk; vlan { members [ Voice Management ]; } native-vlan-id

Re: [Mikrotik] Hopefully a stupid question about VLANs

2011-06-17 Thread Andrew Thrift
Ok, after a bit of digging. SRX and J series do not support Flexible Vlan Tagging meaning you cannot have an untagged native vlan... EX, MX do support this. We have replaced all of our J series with Mikrotik's and any SRX's we sold have been replaced with FortiGates (hence my poor memory)