Re: PF drops tcp packets from a machine with Gentoo linux kernel 2.6.18

2007-02-15 Thread Tim Kuhlman
On Wednesday 14 February 2007 1:29 pm, Stuart Henderson wrote: On 2007/02/14 11:47, Tim Kuhlman wrote: So what is happening? It seems to me that either pf is broken or his linux kernel is broken and pf is catching it. Any ideas as to which is the cause? Ruleset more likely. If you post

Re: PF drops tcp packets from a machine with Gentoo linux kernel 2.6.18

2007-02-15 Thread Tim Kuhlman
Whoops, I forgot about attachments being stripped. $ tcpdump -nr dmz_production_if-side -vv reading from file dmz_production_if-side, link-type EN10MB (Ethernet) 16:32:15.627327 IP (tos 0x0, ttl 63, id 49423, offset 0, flags [DF], proto: TCP (6), length: 60) 10.10.10.150.57818 10.11.0.5.80: S,

Re: PF drops tcp packets from a machine with Gentoo linux kernel 2.6.18

2007-02-15 Thread Darren Spruell
On 2/15/07, Tim Kuhlman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: So my ruleset has some problems. I took some time to work through my rules and re-read the state tracking section of the pf faq (which by the way is well done, thanks). I found what I think are a couple of problems, I needed to have the flags S/SA

Re: PF drops tcp packets from a machine with Gentoo linux kernel 2.6.18

2007-02-15 Thread Tim Kuhlman
On Thursday 15 February 2007 10:12 am, Darren Spruell wrote: On 2/15/07, Tim Kuhlman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: So my ruleset has some problems. I took some time to work through my rules and re-read the state tracking section of the pf faq (which by the way is well done, thanks). I found what

PF drops tcp packets from a machine with Gentoo linux kernel 2.6.18

2007-02-14 Thread Tim Kuhlman
I have pf running on an OpenBSD 4.0 (patches 1-5, 7) router and I have one user with two Gentoo Linux machines with kernel 2.6.18 who is having troubles. Everyone else is having no problem at all. This user is having any tcp connection he makes dropped by the firewall. The state shows up when I

Re: PF drops tcp packets from a machine with Gentoo linux kernel 2.6.18

2007-02-14 Thread Darren Spruell
On 2/14/07, Tim Kuhlman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I have pf running on an OpenBSD 4.0 (patches 1-5, 7) router and I have one user with two Gentoo Linux machines with kernel 2.6.18 who is having troubles. Everyone else is having no problem at all. This user is having any tcp connection he makes

Re: PF drops tcp packets from a machine with Gentoo linux kernel 2.6.18

2007-02-14 Thread Otto Moerbeek
On Wed, 14 Feb 2007, Tim Kuhlman wrote: [snip] So what is happening? It seems to me that either pf is broken or his linux kernel is broken and pf is catching it. Any ideas as to which is the cause? One other point I needs some clarification on, in my searching around I did find an

Re: PF drops tcp packets from a machine with Gentoo linux kernel 2.6.18

2007-02-14 Thread Tim Kuhlman
On Wednesday 14 February 2007 12:11 pm, Darren Spruell wrote: On 2/14/07, Tim Kuhlman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I have pf running on an OpenBSD 4.0 (patches 1-5, 7) router and I have one user with two Gentoo Linux machines with kernel 2.6.18 who is having troubles. Everyone else is having no

Re: PF drops tcp packets from a machine with Gentoo linux kernel 2.6.18

2007-02-14 Thread Stuart Henderson
On 2007/02/14 11:47, Tim Kuhlman wrote: So what is happening? It seems to me that either pf is broken or his linux kernel is broken and pf is catching it. Any ideas as to which is the cause? Ruleset more likely. If you post it, people can make suggestions. Might be useful to capture a SYN

Re: PF drops tcp packets from a machine with Gentoo linux kernel 2.6.18

2007-02-14 Thread Stuart Henderson
On 2007/02/14 12:11, Darren Spruell wrote: Yeah, when I went through it scrub rules had nothing to do with it. All state, period. (Note that in -current the default is now to implicitly build rules with both 'keep state' and 'S/SA' without having to specify; default stateful behavior makes