Re: openospfd vs bird vs quagga etc on OpenBSD for OSPF interoperating with IOS XE (v4 v6)

2013-05-21 Thread Gregory Edigarov
On 05/20/2013 09:22 PM, Chris Cappuccio wrote: Stuart Henderson [s...@spacehopper.org] wrote: Important con here if you're talking about running it on OpenBSD is that this is not a primary platform for them. I think it's safe to say that far fewer people will be running BIRD on OpenBSD than

Re: openospfd vs bird vs quagga etc on OpenBSD for OSPF interoperating with IOS XE (v4 v6)

2013-05-20 Thread Chris Cappuccio
Stuart Henderson [s...@spacehopper.org] wrote: Important con here if you're talking about running it on OpenBSD is that this is not a primary platform for them. I think it's safe to say that far fewer people will be running BIRD on OpenBSD than will be running OpenOSPFd on OpenBSD. Is

Re: openospfd vs bird vs quagga etc on OpenBSD for OSPF interoperating with IOS XE (v4 v6)

2013-05-19 Thread andy
Hi Stuart, Thanks for your great response, all makes perfect sense. I will start with OpenOSPFd and OpenBGPd and see how I get on. I was initially thinking of using BIRD for the previously mentioned reasons, but considering all the points discussed I will start testing, testing testing... Wish

Re: openospfd vs bird vs quagga etc on OpenBSD for OSPF interoperating with IOS XE (v4 v6)

2013-05-18 Thread andy
Hi, Sorry for the slow reply, have just got back home from the RIPE 66 conference in Dublin. Which was great by the way :) Thank you very much for your comments and suggestions. When building something like this it is really important to me to hear the experience and thoughts of others. Ok, so I

Re: openospfd vs bird vs quagga etc on OpenBSD for OSPF interoperating with IOS XE (v4 v6)

2013-05-18 Thread Stuart Henderson
On 2013/05/18 18:10, andy wrote: Hi, Sorry for the slow reply, have just got back home from the RIPE 66 conference in Dublin. Which was great by the way :) Thank you very much for your comments and suggestions. When building something like this it is really important to me to hear the

openospfd vs bird vs quagga etc on OpenBSD for OSPF interoperating with IOS XE (v4 v6)

2013-05-16 Thread andy
Hello, I would like to appeal to the knowledge and experience of this mailing list to offer any opinions/preferences for which routing daemon would be best to use (openospfd or bird or quagga) on OpenBSD when interoperating with Cisco IOS XE routers for redistributing IPv4 and IPv6 routes? I am

Re: openospfd vs bird vs quagga etc on OpenBSD for OSPF interoperating with IOS XE (v4 v6)

2013-05-16 Thread mxb
Quagga might have more features (which you probably don't need at all), but I find it difficult to work with than OpenOSPFD. 1. Configuration in at least two files 2. In order to reload config or to check out state you have to telnet to quagga. E.g. no ospfctl //mxb On 16 maj 2013, at 17:16,

Re: openospfd vs bird vs quagga etc on OpenBSD for OSPF interoperating with IOS XE (v4 v6)

2013-05-16 Thread Loïc BLOT
Openbsd and openbgpd are working Like a charm With CISCO and alcatel routers. With openbsd routing daemon you can also backup the ospf configurations and create différent versions. Also the debug is simpler Loic Blot Le 16 mai 2013 à 17:45, mxb m...@alumni.chalmers.se a écrit : Quagga might

Re: openospfd vs bird vs quagga etc on OpenBSD for OSPF interoperating with IOS XE (v4 v6)

2013-05-16 Thread Stuart Henderson
On 2013-05-16, andy a...@brandwatch.com wrote: Hello, I would like to appeal to the knowledge and experience of this mailing list to offer any opinions/preferences for which routing daemon would be best to use (openospfd or bird or quagga) on OpenBSD when interoperating with Cisco IOS XE