Today at Carleton College on Lyman Lakes there were probably a couple hundred 
of the usual Canadas. It seemed as though the nominal, lesser, and giant races 
were all represented. One Cackling Goose which I found only at about 6 pm was 
also present. An unidentified goose was present from at least 9:30 AM until 6 PM

Pictures of the goose are located here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/7851430 at 
N06/2963109978/ and here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/7851430 at 
N06/2963109964/

If those don't work, the homepage, with the photos at the top of the page, is 
here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/7851430 at N06/

Snow, Ross', or something in between? It could also be part domestic, which was 
my first thought because of the strange bill and neck, but when seen out of the 
water it did not have the deep belly typical of domestics and appeared fully 
capable of flight. I talked to Gene Bauer, a Carleton birder and we were both 
unsure.  Much about the face suggests Snow (and that's probably what it is), 
but it would still have to be a small Snow if it is one, as it appears much 
smaller than the Canadas in the photo, which were smaller than most Canadas I 
see.  It certainly was not larger than the lone Cackler on the lake.

Experts feel free to weigh in!

Also, thanks to all those who wrote messages of welcome.  I feel like I'm 
already more a part of the birding community here than I was in Chicago.  The 
trip to the Gunflint trail was pretty good.  Since it was primarily a Geology 
trip, I was mostly looking at rocks and I didn't have as much freedom of 
movement as I had hoped, but I did see PURPLE FINCHES, SNOW BUNTINGS, a 
NORTHERN SHRIKE, and a male and female RUFFED GROUSE, all of which are no big 
deal for Northern Minnesota, but still good birds for a Chicagoan.  The male 
Ruffed Grouse was displaying to the female, with tail fully spread and neck 
feathers erect.  I thought this might be curious behavior for mid-October.

--Owen McMurtrey
Carleton College
Rice County

Reply via email to