Re: Goals, Worldviews, Policies

2005-03-17 Thread Ian G
Gervase Markham wrote: Ian G wrote: Here's my view: we are already in State B. Can you point to any financial losses caused by someone falsely trusting certs issued by CAs trusted by Firefox? In answer to your question, no. But this does not show we are not in State B. As you've elided the def

Re: Goals, Worldviews, Policies

2005-03-17 Thread Gervase Markham
Ian G wrote: Here's my view: we are already in State B. Can you point to any financial losses caused by someone falsely trusting certs issued by CAs trusted by Firefox? Enacting the policy will IMHO make no difference to the state, because we are already there. I would have thought that was abu

Re: Goals, Worldviews, Policies

2005-03-16 Thread J. Greenlees
Ian G wrote: Nelson just posted a bug comment, but I think the response and discussion of the points he raised are too broad for that bug, so I'll move them here, if nobody minds. I have two points to make here - the reality of the CA "trust" decision, and the goal. [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: https:/

Goals, Worldviews, Policies

2005-03-16 Thread Ian G
Nelson just posted a bug comment, but I think the response and discussion of the points he raised are too broad for that bug, so I'll move them here, if nobody minds. I have two points to make here - the reality of the CA "trust" decision, and the goal. [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: https://bugzilla.moz