[MP3 ENCODER] LAME ID3 version 2 support proposal

2000-06-25 Thread Don Melton
Gang, I have a proposal for adding ID3 version 2 tag support to LAME. Why? Well, someone asked about it on the mailing list several weeks ago and I was bored and just wanted to make a contribution again. :-) Actually, since version 2 tags are normally the first frame of an MPEG audio stream,

Re: [MP3 ENCODER] LAME ID3 version 2 support proposal

2000-06-25 Thread Gabriel Bouvigne
So ... comments? Does anyone not want this feature? How about a different behavior? Or should I just start typing away now? :-) I personnally don't use the lame id3 options. But, personnally, I'd like to have by default both v1 and v2 tags if v2 are necessarry (ie more than 30 char), as

Re: [MP3 ENCODER] LAME ID3 version 2 support proposal

2000-06-25 Thread Don Melton
On Sun, Jun 25, 2000 at 11:33:20AM +0200, Gabriel Bouvigne wrote: So ... comments? Does anyone not want this feature? How about a different behavior? Or should I just start typing away now? :-) I personnally don't use the lame id3 options. But, personnally, I'd like to have by default

Re: [MP3 ENCODER] LAME ID3 version 2 support proposal

2000-06-25 Thread highroad
Not really. Take a look at my streaming MP3 station on Live365 at http://www.live365.com/cgi-bin/directory.cgi?autostart=wtgfs and you'll see the info from the ID3 version 1 tags for all clips. The server, which of course runs much faster than the internet connection, simply reads the ID3

Re: [MP3 ENCODER] LAME ID3 version 2 support proposal

2000-06-25 Thread Sigbjørn Skjæret
Why add version 2 tags at all? Version 1 tags are virtually useless within streaming audio (since they don't appear until the end of the stream), so version 2 tag support is essential for that type of application. Not really. Take a look at my streaming MP3 station on Live365 at

Re: [MP3 ENCODER] LAME ID3 version 2 support proposal

2000-06-25 Thread Zia Mazhar
I guess ID3v2 tag doesn't cause any conflict anywhere... Does it? Is it possible to keep both version of tags? Then, the programs which do not support v2 may read the v1 tag... But I guess that'll confuse most of the players [if not all of them!] because they probably are not specifically