2006/10/1, Dave Smey [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
On Sun, October 1, 2006 12:08 pm, Dave Smey said: 2 - Should specifically VA releases where the title puts a strong accent on the performer be stored under the performer?
Yes.I believe this is the current practice, with a description buried somewhere deep
Maybe a bit on a tangent (again), and maybe its already
incorporated in the "rules"
Just wondering if anyone has looked at the "rules"
librarians use for their music collections.
A.they could become major users and supporters of MB if the
system has advantages for them
B. that profession has
Good day all,
I was entering AR's this other day, and noticed that perfoms as in
both the server UI and related wiki pages is defined so that it's
specifically meant for links between individuals.
Even if I agree that this relationship is usually suitable mainly for
individuals, but I think
Frederic and I have has a few correspondences off list, and I am also
convinced that the Classical Style Guide needs updating to account for
recital discs - releases with one performer playing a variety of
repertoire.
His original language was:
2 - Should specifically VA releases where the title
Dave Smey wrote:
My proposed language would be: Recitals by a particular artist: In
cases where a release contains works from multiple composers but all
works are attributable to a single group or performer, that group or
performer may
be designated the ReleaseArtist, with each TrackArtist
On Mon, October 2, 2006 5:46 pm, Christopher Aillon said:
Why won't it? As I understand it, it will still show up in the exact
same spot it shows up in Bach's artist page right now. Or is there
something blatantly obvious that I'm missing?
Well, yes. The ARs currently look like ass, for
Dave Smey wrote:
On Mon, October 2, 2006 5:46 pm, Christopher Aillon said:
Why won't it? As I understand it, it will still show up in the exact
same spot it shows up in Bach's artist page right now. Or is there
something blatantly obvious that I'm missing?
Well, yes. The ARs currently look
Christopher Aillon replies to Dave Smey:
Clearly you aren't a classical music fan. Many composers have such a
wide array of material that I'm in the mood for some Bach might as
well be I'm in the mood to listen to music. Which Bach? C.P.E
perhaps. Maybe C.F, or J.C. Seriously,
