Re: [mb-style] "from the beginning" and "until the end" attributes for "member of" AR

On 28/01/2009 6:01 a.m., Philip Jägenstedt wrote: > On Tue, Jan 27, 2009 at 6:37 PM, Gioele wrote: > >> Aaron Cooper wrote: >> >> >>> Can't we just give the member the same start date as the band? >>> >> It leads to unnecessary duplication of data. Also it is more difficult to >

Re: [mb-style] "from the beginning" and "until the end" attributes for "member of" AR

On Tue, Jan 27, 2009 at 6:37 PM, Gioele wrote: > Aaron Cooper wrote: > >> Can't we just give the member the same start date as the band? > It leads to unnecessary duplication of data. Also it is more difficult to keep > consistent. A band with 5 members would require 6 modifications to change a >

Re: [mb-style] "from the beginning" and "until the end" attributes for "member of" AR

Aaron Cooper wrote: > Can't we just give the member the same start date as the band? It leads to unnecessary duplication of data. Also it is more difficult to keep consistent. A band with 5 members would require 6 modifications to change a begin or end date. -- Gioele

Re: [mb-style] "from the beginning" and "until the end" attributes for "member of" AR

On Tue, Jan 27, 2009 at 10:48 AM, Gioele wrote: > Could add two attributes: "From the beginning" and "To the end" to the > "member of" AR? With these attributes we could easy express that a certain > artist has been a member of a group from its inception to the (eventual) > end. Also one could say

Re: [mb-style] "from the beginning" and "until the end" attributes for "member of" AR

+1> To: musicbrainz-style@lists.musicbrainz.org> From: gio...@svario.it> Date: Tue, 27 Jan 2009 16:48:56 +0100> Subject: [mb-style] "from the beginning" and "until the end" attributes for "member of" AR> > Could add two attributes: "From the beginning" and "To the end" to the> "member of" AR? W

[mb-style] "from the beginning" and "until the end" attributes for "member of" AR

Could add two attributes: "From the beginning" and "To the end" to the "member of" AR? With these attributes we could easy express that a certain artist has been a member of a group from its inception to the (eventual) end. Also one could say that an artist has been "member of" a group "from beginn

Re: [mb-style] RFC: Revised Comprehensive CSG Proposal::Current State of the Propsal

2009/1/27 Brian Schweitzer > On Tue, Jan 27, 2009 at 4:34 AM, Frederic Da Vitoria > wrote: > >> 2009/1/27 Brian Schweitzer >> >>> On Tue, Jan 27, 2009 at 3:39 AM, Frederic Da Vitoria < >>> davito...@gmail.com> wrote: >>> We could agree that until mbWorks are implemented the WorksLists woul

Re: [mb-style] RFC: Revised Comprehensive CSG Proposal::Current State of the Propsal

On Tue, Jan 27, 2009 at 4:34 AM, Frederic Da Vitoria wrote: > 2009/1/27 Brian Schweitzer > >> On Tue, Jan 27, 2009 at 3:39 AM, Frederic Da Vitoria > > wrote: >> >>> We could agree that until mbWorks are implemented the WorksLists would >>> have to go through a voting process once they have been m

Re: [mb-style] RFC: Revised Comprehensive CSG Proposal::Current State of the Propsal

2009/1/27 Brian Schweitzer > On Tue, Jan 27, 2009 at 3:39 AM, Frederic Da Vitoria > wrote: > >> We could agree that until mbWorks are implemented the WorksLists would >> have to go through a voting process once they have been more or less >> stabilised. Of course, voting would impossible while t

Re: [mb-style] RFC: Revised Comprehensive CSG Proposal::Current State of the Propsal

On Tue, Jan 27, 2009 at 3:39 AM, Frederic Da Vitoria wrote: > 2009/1/27 symphonick > >> 2009/1/27, Frederic Da Vitoria : >> > 2009/1/27 symphonick >> >> 3. a related issue: language - did we have a consensus about using the >> >> language of the catalogue or composer? I think I'd prefer Norwegia

Re: [mb-style] RFC: Revised Comprehensive CSG Proposal::Current State of the Propsal

2009/1/27 Brian Schweitzer > On Mon, Jan 26, 2009 at 6:15 PM, symphonick wrote: > >> 2009/1/26, Brian Schweitzer : >> > Current state of the proposal: >> > >> > Ok, let's see if we can't get this wrapped up! It's been a long 13+ >> months >> > since this proposal began it's journey towards a re

Re: [mb-style] RFC: Revised Comprehensive CSG Proposal::Current State of the Propsal

2009/1/27 symphonick > 2009/1/27, Frederic Da Vitoria : > > 2009/1/27 symphonick > >> 3. a related issue: language - did we have a consensus about using the > >> language of the catalogue or composer? I think I'd prefer Norwegian > >> for Grieg, French for Debussy & German for JSBach, but I'm no

Re: [mb-style] RFC: Revised Comprehensive CSG Proposal::Current State of the Propsal

On Mon, Jan 26, 2009 at 6:15 PM, symphonick wrote: > 2009/1/26, Brian Schweitzer : > > Current state of the proposal: > > > > Ok, let's see if we can't get this wrapped up! It's been a long 13+ > months > > since this proposal began it's journey towards a real CSG. :) > > > > This week, I will

Re: [mb-style] RFC: Revised Comprehensive CSG Proposal::Current State of the Propsal

On Tue, Jan 27, 2009 at 3:08 AM, symphonick wrote: > 2009/1/27, Brian Schweitzer : > >> > >> > Finally, the last remaining CSG-works issue: what to do with Da > capas, > >> > segnos, Dal segns, and codas? This is the unfinished section of > >> CSG-works > >> > at > >> > > >> > http://wiki.music

Re: [mb-style] RFC: Revised Comprehensive CSG Proposal::Current State of the Propsal

2009/1/27, Frederic Da Vitoria : > 2009/1/27 symphonick > >> 1. When should we duplicate / create a new work (worklist entry)? what >> goes for different instrumentation of the same music - string quartet >> is played with flute + string trio, a keyboard sonata with guitar, or >> maybe Mozart's G-

Re: [mb-style] RFC: Revised Comprehensive CSG Proposal::Current State of the Propsal

2009/1/27, Brian Schweitzer : >> >> > Finally, the last remaining CSG-works issue: what to do with Da capas, >> > segnos, Dal segns, and codas? This is the unfinished section of >> CSG-works >> > at >> > >> http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/BrianFreud/sandbox?highlight=(sandbox)#CSGdacapostructure